This rating is based on customer reviews, inventory size, pricing, and service quality
In Seattle Hill, WA, Andy's Auto Repair scores 90/100 with an overall highly positive trend. Reviews highlight Danny’s professionalism, clear communication, and fair, competitive pricing, plus fast turnarounds and flexible scheduling; many long‑term customers report reliable fixes across Hondas, Subarus, and more. Strengths include transparency, warranty support, and helpful diagnostics. Common complaints: a costly transmission job, an oil‑change bill higher than quoted, a misdiagnosis fee, and one brake issue left unresolved. Limited or no info on inventory variety, yard organization, or parts‑finding.
What clients say about Andy's Auto Repair in Seattle Hill (WA)
I requested an estimate for a timing belt replacement for an older model Honda Civic. I did not go with Andy's Auto Repair for the service because another mechanic had more prior history with my vehicle and given how old it is, I thought it was the safer option to avoid any additional /unexpected repairs that may emerge. Andy's quote was very competitive -- it was roughly 1/2 the price of other quotes I received.
What was great about Andy's Auto: Danny, who runs the shop, called me back promptly with an estimate and broke it down, explaining all that was involved and what wasn't in scope. This was important given how involved this repair would be. He said his shop uses high quality gaskets and other parts from a reputable supplier -- these "after market" parts. Danny said he has a lot of experience with this type of repair and provided useful background information that was instructive.
Went to get service for a transmission with cost $2000 which cost me an extra 1400 and he did something wrong to one of my sensors which leads me to get a new converter this guy is about money and not about the neighbors So if you’re trying to get your car fixed, please pass by this guy I do not recommend him. He’s up to a scam to try to rip people off for one bolt and screw.
If your looking to put your money on a small family owned business this one has never disappointed. The son now runs the company . His mom runs the office . Very knowagable I brought both my Subarus here don't matter day or night he's quick and he'll put in my parts . Five stars for me .
Andy’s Auto Shop is fantastic! Danny is reliable, honest, and always fair with pricing. I’ve been coming here for about four years and would recommend him to anyone. His prices are significantly cheaper than the Honda dealership, and the service is always top-notch. Highly recommend!
"I left my Volvo with this shop for two weeks, only to be charged a diagnostic fee for an incorrect diagnosis. They were unable to repair the vehicle and wasted both my time and money. I would not recommend this shop for specialized repairs.
I needed a car battery asap. After calling many other places I was finally able to speak with someone. Danny took my information and called me back in less than 20 minutes. He let me know that he had a battery available. I showed up to his shop right a 2pm as scheduled, he changed out my battery, checked my oil and made sure all was perfect before I left. 10 Star service!! Thank you to Danny at Andy’s Auto Repair!
Ran into a problem while going to work and instead of calling a tow truck I called Andy’s and luckily there was an opening. Got me in and when once done he went through everything and I’m satisfied with his work. Will come again
Danny at Andy’s Automotive was so incredibly helpful in a quick turnaround, excellent service & dedication from this team with very fair pricing! Will definitely become my regular mechanic in Green Lake.
They were available on short notice to take in my car. Great transparent communication. Diagnosed and fixed my issue quickly, and advised of other concerns with the vehicle to consider servicing in the future. Overall a great experience, would recommend and bring our vehicles here in the future!
I was recommended this shop on Facebook making a post asking if anyone in my area knew of affordable auto shops for an oil change that wouldn’t try to upsell me on any other services. I called the shop the day before and asked for an estimate for an oil change. After describing the make, model, year, etc. of my car, the man estimated it would cost about 80-90 dollars. I said great and said I would drop off my car the next morning. I dropped off my car the next morning and said I just wanted an oil change and the man was very friendly (I think his name was Danny) and after a few hours he called and said my car was ready to be picked up. When I got back to the shop I saw a receipt for my totaling $162. He explained that he topped off my windshield wiper fluid, break fluid, yadda yadda and it would be $162. I don’t know much about cars and I should have said something but I just handed him my card and left. Now I have an extremely sour taste in my mouth about this place because I was specifically looking for a place that would not overcharge or upsell me or take advantage of my lack of knowledge and Andy’s Auto Repair seems to be just that! Super disappointed and will be telling the woman who recommended me this spot, too.
Danny was very quick and efficient with getting my car together. He has great customer service and the cutest mother. lol my car is running good and he insured a warranty on anything he has fixed so that was awesome. He’s a lot more affordable than Chucks. I can say that!
I’ve been bringing my Honda here for service in the last five years. The fee is very reasonable, Andy explains clearly the issues, his recommendation and cost. Haven’t got any problems since. Highly recommended.
I had the weirdest wobbling sound coming from my back door. At Andy’s they helped narrow down and finally identify and fix the noise issue. Really friendly and fast turnaround. Highly recommend
Danny is a great mechanic and takes great pride in his work. He’s punctual and honest. My car had sat in the driveway way for 3+ years and was took it in for some badly needed maintenance. Not only is the car running great, but he had the car washed for free, as a courtesy. He also helped a friend get her car quickly back on the road after N accident she had. I highly recommend Andy’s Auto and will be using them as my mechanic going forward.
Ive been using Andy's for 30 years. Theyre fair, very experienced and do an excellent job. I have no complaints. Danny and company are extremely polite and friendly. They know what theyre doing. I feel VERY lucky to have found them. Theyve been in business a long time at one location and it's a 2nd generation shop! Award-winning.
Danny did a great job getting my car running again after it sat for a year. Great at explaining the problems and explaining future maintenance that he recommends.
Danny at Andy’s Auto Repair takes great care of our cars. I recently needed repairs done to my car, and he worked around my schedule, which was tight and not particularly flexible. He was able to get the work done in the stated timeline with good communication all along the way. I would highly recommend taking your car to Andy’s Auto Repair.
Danny's customer service was top notch, he changed my oil and rotated my tires and topped off all my fluids, let me know what problems to be on the lookout for and was very reasonable with pricing. Support local!
I’ve been a customer for 17 years; I moved to Kitsap County 7 years ago and happily make the 2 hour commute to take my car here for servicing and repairs. Andy’s Auto is a family business with a long history of honest, ethical, transparent and reliable service. Like his father before him, Danny gives great guidance on what repairs are needed immediately and what can wait. Danny is a like a car detective, he really knows how to research a problem and figure out a fix. Equally skilled with old or new cars. I’ll never go elsewhere, you don’t find service like this easily.
Amazing experience here! Dan could not have been nicer and my car drives so much better after going. He communicated clearly and made me feel in the know (as someone who doesn’t know much about cars). A real family-feel. I will be coming here for all my car needs! Thank you!
Love having this in the neighborhood!
I've been coming to Andy's for years and they've always been fast and honest with me. Danny is great and and can usually get me an appointment quickly. I highly recommend
Had an issue come up, called and managed to get the car in next morning. Really communicative, helpful and felt that they kept cost in mind with their approach. Not many local community mechanics left and grateful I found this one for the future!
Dan is incredible. After a pretty rough accident, we towed our car to him to get fixed after seeing some positive Google Reviews and chatting on the phone about the damage. Throughout our entire experience, Dan was communicative, kind, and very knowledgeable. After this experience, he’s got our business forever now. If you’re looking to support a local family-run business, give Dan a call — especially if you’re driving a Subaru.
While the car shop looks a bit rundown from the outside, it excels in customer service. I wasn't there for 'cucumber water' and a sleek-dressed salesperson trying to upsell unnecessary services. I visited for a full brake job, transmission and engine oil changes, and I'm thrilled with the results.
Danny was one of the best car mechanics I've dealt with: punctual, straightforward, knowledgeable, and competent. Coupled with very fair and competitive pricing, it's a combination that's hard to find in today's car repair businesses. I hope they continue to thrive!
Danny is an old school mechanic that knows his stuff. I believe he’s the only guy (owner) running Andy’s auto, so you don’t have to worry about it getting passed off to somebody that inexperienced (which has happened to me in the past). Honest guy with fair prices for the work done! Will go back for any future work!
I've been taking both my cars here for years and Danny is trustworthy and capable. My two vehicles have 400k miles between them and Danny has always found solutions to keep them running smoothly at a reasonable price.
How this mechanic can stay in business is beyond me. I did not have a good experience. I spent $1k+ and the same car problem persists. When I asked Dan how was the test drive and did the problem go away. He said yes, there is no more problem. I drove it, the brake was soft and the car still pulls to the left. So not only did he not fix my car problem now the car is got more problems than when i dropped it off. Also, now braking is loud. Needless to say, im very disappointed and won't be taking my car there again.
This is a true multi-generation family business with a real mechanic. Danny knows cars and has kept my Subaru running great. He is busy but why would you want a mechanic that is not in demand? Reliable troubleshooting at a fair price.
My issue was my head and taillights kept randomly turning on when the car was off and parked, making my battery die whether at home or away. Carter Subaru wanted to replace battery, all lights, and other repairs. These mechanics fixed my issue by watching my car all day then simply tightening my brake pedal. Honest, trustworthy, and didn’t charge me! I have used their services ever since.
Website
