Brothers Auto Parts in
Indianapolis (IN)

I often visit them to get some special parts for our repair shop. Tennessee is a sales person I always look for. She always patiently listened to my concerns and asked the right questions to point me in the right direction. She always helps finding me several options that fit my budget and requirements.

I have been doing business with brothers prior to Fenix for abt 15 years but my latest experience has me severing ties with them they’re rude, unprofessional and they definitely do not value you as a customer

Used to be decent before Fenix took over. Now you can never get anyone on the phone and if you have an issue they just hang up on you or send you to a random voicemail and don't say anything. Cost me $15 for them to send the incorrect parts. You don't get anyone local just some random person somewhere in the country working from home that has no idea about anything after sitting on hold for 20 minutes. Will be passing them over for parts in the future for sure.

This is the first time I have ever felt the need to review a place, unfortunately. So after a moderate wait to get in touch with someone, I had a phone conversation looking for a part and clarifying that they had it on hand. There were two possible options, they said they had both on hand. I asked if I could match my current one up to make sure I received the correct one, they said yes. I explained that for my job, I am rarely in town, so didn't know until usually the day of, if I would be able to make it in... also mentioned that I lived farther away, they said not a problem. Fast forward roughly a week, I had some time to make it there during their difficult to make business hours. Took me roughly 4 hours round trip, and over $30 in gas, only to walk in and be told that they don't have the parts on hand, they are at a sister location, a state away. After that, they also told me that they wouldn't have pulled it same day anyways. I mentioned how far I drove, after having a phone conversation with a representative the week prior, they didn't even apologize for the lack of communication or anything. Needless to say if I was supposed to know without saying that they don't pull parts same day, and that they would lie to me about having a part on hand for me to check... they are not someone I would recommend doing business with. They should also know without me saying to them, that this review would be posted, and that I will never do any business with them. I guess the only redeeming quality was that since no one was rude, they deserve one star.

I had a good and easy experience when visiting this store for parts. A lady named Tennessee Voorheis was very helpful and kind. Would visit again.

I was assisted by Tennessee V. and she did an excellent job in getting my parts list for my brake work.

Fenix parts is awesome! I needed a radiator and water pump for my 68 Volkswagen beetle and Tennessee found exactly what I needed!

Bought a radius arm for my Ford in great shape from Tennessee. One of the few places that still has them and knew what they were!

Tennessee was amazing at finding the parts I needed. I definitely will be recommending her to my friends for their future parts needs. Thank you again Tennessee!!!!!

Tennessee is for sure amazing. Been looking for a turn signal switch and just the switch everywhere else was $300+, she got me a whole new column for under $100. Thank you so much ms Tennessee. Youre an angel.

Tennessee helped me quote my dad some parts and she’s so sweet. Amazing customer service and her care for her customers are extraordinary.

I only go to Tennessee for my parts. She makes sure they’re of quality and not damaged before being sent out. Goes above and beyond to do her job and sometimes others as well. Someone give her a raise!

Great quality used parts here! And when it comes to customer service!?! Tennessee has you covered at the front desk, she is very knowledgeable and always willing to go the distance for her customers!

I received some of the best service I ever have in my life! Tennessee was very helpful and very informative I will definitely be back

Great place to get quality parts. I had a great experience with Tennessee she knew exactly what parts I needed and she did a fantastic job she is sweet and pleasant to be around she deserves a raise if u ask me

Never on time with parts if they Even get you the right parts the first time. Pretty over priced for used parts gotta pay before they make you wait days and days for parts. They have like 2 sales people trying to run the whole state. Got rid of the whole staff for some reason so it's so hard to talk to someone. But the lil old lady in the back who handles money I think is a gem.

Fenix is awesome, very knowledgeable and very polite. Fast retrieval of parts and Tennessee was so helpful and really knew what I was looking for. Ask for her when you go in!!!

If your looking for parts or a job do yourself a favor and stay away from this place there parts are over priced and sometimes dont work properly and good luck getting your money back branden and andrew are rude not professional and the employees get treated like trash save your time and money go somewhere else because fenix auto parts is definitely not a place to go

This place is horrible. I paid for the parts before I even went and they gave me the wrong parts.. a few days later they tried to give me aftermarket junk. I returned them for a refund and it has been over 2 weeks and I still have not received my refund. I'm going to call the BBB and see if they are even a member

I recommend NOT ordering from these people. I ordered a radio and they sent me one that doesn’t work. It’s been over a month trying to get this returned so I can get my money back and they keep making every excuse under the sun or they just don’t call me back. Literally the worst customer service I’ve ever dealt with! Again…. save your money and time and do NOT order from here!

I had an accident and Brothers was recommended. The waiting room was so clean. Service exceptional. Received updates on work weekly. Work completed as promised and it looked great. Car clean when it was done. Great job Team Brothers!

This establishment consistently delivers on their promise of good service. The sales team, including both men and women, is top-notch. The facility is consistently well-maintained, and the warranty they offer is impressive. The staff is friendly and incredibly well-informed. You can bet I'll be a loyal customer

Went yesterday to get a back window for ram. Said it would be done yesterday or this morning. Went today in the morning. To get it. Going out of town. Went to get it they said it's not ready and won't be until Thursday. I offered to tip the auto tech $100 cash to expedite it. The manager said no and all he could do was do a refund. I said do that then because I had to go find a window today. He told the desk guy to go ahead and process a refund. The guy then got up and walked out the door to the garage. I was confused by this and was not happy at this time. I said loudly is someone going to process my refund. The guy second down from the door looked at me and said hey chill out. That made me mad so I just turned and walked out. Update, Could find a window that day. After I got home I went first thing to go get the window since the refund wasn't process. No biggy when I showed up they said I could pick it up and send me out to the garage. The manager came out and said you put that bad review in, we cancelled your order. Talk about treating the customer right. Was going to take the review off until they did this. Some business just don't know how to say sorry when they make a mistakes.

Definitely wont purchase from this business again. Make sure you check your invoice at least 5 times before sliding your card because they will try to rip you off. Speaking with the manager also doesn’t help so here i’m leaving my honest review from my experience.

Called yesterday morning and spoke with Cindy. Ordered a reservoir coolant tank. Paid with a credit card over the phone and Cindy told me the part would be ready in a couple days. Cindy called me yesterday afternoon and informed me that my part was ready. I picked it up this morning. I searched other salvage yards and could not find one. E-bay wanted over twice what I paid at Brothers. Very satisfied with customer service, the part and definitely the price. Thanks Cindy!

I had the worst experience in the hands of Jeremiah Johnson, a guy who claimed to be the owner of the business. After making me wait for more than a week for my parts, he abruptly ended the sale just because I said his customer service agent - a guy called Jose, lied to me by giving me delivery dates that he could not honor. Jeremiah, the so-called owner came at me screaming with so much arrogance, unprofessionalism and anger that I couldn’t imagine how he has been in business all this time. This is the last place I would ever recommend to anyone. Poor customer service and very hostile atmosphere shown to me by Jeremiah Johnson. The guy needs help because his emotions are seemingly abnormal.

One star is generous. If they have the part you need so does someone else. Call around and buy it from them it will be worth your time & effort to do so. This place doesn't even know what customer service is. I drove 2hrs from Cincinnati to purchase wheels & tires from them. I had them send several detailed pics of the items. We agreed on a price & I offered to give them $100 deposit till I got there Friday. They said they don't take deposits. So I told them I'd be there Friday it was my off day. They call Wednesday & say sorry man we sold the tires. I told them I'd still be there Friday to get the wheels. (It's what I needed most anyway). I call Friday morning and tell them I'm on my way and they say ok wheels are still here. I get about 20 minutes from Indianapolis and they call to tell me that on Wednesday when they took the tires off they damaged the wheels. ( they should have told me Wednesday or at least Friday morning when I said I was headed their way) I would've known not to go. So he says well we will give you a discount, I get there and they offer me $20 off. Which in my opinion is ridiculous when it's their screw up. So I decided not to get the wheels but wanted to buy a rubber tray that went in my console($5 on eBay ) and he says we have a $40 minimum. After they screw up my wheels they still try to give me the shaft. So needless to say I bought nothing. I did Google other yards in Indy and went home with with the same set of wheels cheaper and in great shape. My thing is we all make mistakes it's just how you handle it. I HIGHLY recommend going elsewhere. If there is a rebuttal from them I have all the pics & texts from them so twist it how you want. I've told everyone I know and everyone I ran into in Indy how bad the service is. I hope this helps anyone reading this to go elsewhere. Thanks and good day too you.