This rating is based on customer reviews, inventory size, pricing, and service quality
Reviews for Baughman's U-Pull-It in York Springs, PA skew positive with an overall score of 85/100. Customers praise fair pricing, a large mostly older inventory, vehicles set on stands, and an accurate online listing/notifications that make parts easier to find. Staff is often described as friendly and helpful, towing and sell‑offs are quick, and the yard is fairly organized, though lanes can be messy. Complaints center on rude encounters, core-charge policies and refund windows, occasional overpricing, picked‑clean rows, early entry cutoffs, and uneven grouping. Overall, good value for DIYers.
What clients say about Baughman's U-Pull-It in York Springs (PA)
If I could give 0 stars I would. Called twice on Wednesday 2/25/26 at 10:30am & the lady representive (if you call it that) picked up where you could hear her breathing so I knew she was there. Wouldn't say, 'hello,' etc. The second attempt at a phone call she yells: 'Do you expect me to answer you?!' That is your JOB isn't it? Nope. Save your time and money - never again,
This places sucks, Customer service sucks, the girl that works there is rude and not help along with that management just being rude in general do not recommend coming here.
I recently discovered this gem. Prices are fair when compared to other in the York/Lancaster area. Great selection of vehicles with plenty of parts. I guess the only down side is a hiccup with my money. I paid my entrance fee with a $10 bill and later realized I only got $3 back. Also, no one asked if I brought a core when I checked out (which I did). I didn't think about it until I saw my core still in my truck. It was only a few bucks so no big deal. Even with these glitches, it was an awesome experience. I'll definitely be back.
I didn't get the car part I needed. They said the model is still being processed and will be in the yard next week. You gotta bring your own tools to get the parts, and it's 2 bucks to get in.
Everything was amazing.
Our Server Simona was 100% on the mark and provided great servce. She is amazing and RtC Diner is my fave. Need to come here more often.
This place not only over charges for used parts. But also charges you a deposit on cores wich they do not post on the receipt that you only have 30 days to get your money back on core. Further stealing from the customer. I personally know of many other places who charge both cores not sticking there hand further in a customer's pocket. Hope it was worth 11 dollars to loose a customer and many other I might have recommended.
I have to tell you that I absolutely love Baughman’s U-Pull it! If you are a bit handy need a part for your car head right over there and don’t forget your tools. They keep their inventory online so you can check what row your donor car is in before you go. Their staff is friendly and prices are good. Wear play clothes and boots - playing in the mud is part of the joy of U-Pull It junkyarding!
Love it here, bring your own tools some good waterproof boots, and a outfit you won't mind getting dirty, and something to carry your goodies thats sturdy because the area can be muddy, friendly staff and just an over all cool place .
Small, but organized. Staff has always been very polite. Unfortunately their pricing is more on par with much larger, more established junkyards (including core charges on items like doors), so I really only come out here if they happen to have something I absolutely need.
The staff are friendly, the yard is kept clean, and the prices are reasonable. Their inventory notification system is great! I was notified as soon as the car I needed was stocked. Great selection of vehicles.
Great place for u pull it parts. Have a huge selection of GM and Ford vehicles. Multiple cars for the model I needed. Yard is organized and the staff are helpful in pointing you in the right direction. Prices are very good vs other used part yards. The have wheel barrows available for use. Lots of debris in the lanes, makes it a little difficult if you have a cart.
Iive used baughmans before no problem this last time was different i was given the price of 415 for my 08 honda odyssey touring edition that is fully loaded w tv everything w out my catalytic converters but when they showed up told me only 315 because they were missing but they knew before they picked it up they were missing and its false advertisement when you advertise cash for cars cause i got a check
It's laid out pretty decent. It does cost 2 bucks a person to get in. Bring your own tools. Their prices are quite reasonable. Most of what I've seen is from 90s up. And they rotate their stock just about every 90 days. They don't rotate their stock out at once just a row here and there a week But it all gets switched out in just about 90 days.
I took my 2004 Jeep Grand Cherokee with 207,000 miles on it to Baughmans and got a very good price for it! The people working there were very nice and polite. They took care of me in minutes. I would definitely recommend them to anyone.
They have a fairly good selection but most are 15 plus years or older. I'm in no way complaining. It's nice to be able to find older vehicle parts! My only gripe is I wish they would put alike makes together better.
Friendly staff. Got an immaculate hood. Decent front bumper and grille for my 2nd gen honda odyssey. Hood latch mechanism. Everything for under a 100 bucks cant beat it. I'll be returning for future needs.
As a rebuilder and reseller, this is my favorite yard to shop! I'm not just saying that because the owner is a friend. Always a great variety of vehicles and not picked to the bone like the larger yards. It's very well laid out and the employees are awesome. Keep on doing great things guys and I will see you soon.
This place definitely provides a good service. Well organized with more than fair pricing. I was able to find what I consider some hard to get parts. I needed a pair of sun visors for an old Mitsubishi Spyder and a power antenna for the same car. I paid my $2 admission and the guy told me exactly where to look and he was exactly right. Just go prepared with tools to remove your own parts.
I absolutely love this place unfortunately though you must be at the front gate before 5pm otherwise you will not be able to purchase your parts. So don't get distracted when it's close to closing time....like me
Nicely organized and laid out. One of the few places you can search for a car before going and wasting time. prices aren't too bad at all, lower that some other local places depending on the part you need. Only downside, and for me its a big one. If you have a kid, and no one to watch them. They aren't allowed to enter with you, like a lot of local places do. I would have thought to keep customers they would offer a "We Pull" option with a small fee. However they do not. So if you have kids, no one to watch them, and you need a part, this is not the location for you. For me all I needed was an air box. Maybe a 5 minute pull. Really disappointing since I use to go there quite often before we moved and we started using the local one to us. But with our local yards huge price increase on parts I was wanting to drive back to Baughman's since i had always had a positive experience, Including being able to bring a minor in with a waver.
The staff is easy to work with and very helpful, selection is good but a bit scattered. Prices are very reasonable. Bring a good selection of tools and come early in the morning to get a wheelbarrow. Some vehicles may require the staff to reposition the jackstands for you to get what you need, I noticed some cars had shifted and could be tricky to pull parts off from them. Overall, I will be going back there quite a bit
They had what I needed! that said, the yard is average sized, pricing was right on with their website price list. The owner was a nice guy who used to be into drag racing and had a auto repair shop prior so he knows his stuff. Sum it up, I will be going back in the future because of the great location and reasonable prices. I didn't give 5 stars due to size.
Website
