This rating is based on customer reviews, inventory size, pricing, and service quality
In East Rochester, NY, Keystone Automotive - Rochester scores 74/100 with sentiment mixed but leaning positive. Many cite helpful, professional staff, fair pricing at times, and a strong selection of aftermarket and hard‑to‑find body parts, plus no‑hassle returns and next‑day delivery. Drawbacks: long phone hold times and hang‑ups, occasional higher‑than‑expected prices, limited‑hours perceptions, and confusion after a move; one review reports a troubling company‑truck incident. Inventory seems solid, but yard organization and on‑site ease of finding parts are unclear; sample may be limited.
What clients say about Keystone Automotive - Rochester in East Rochester (NY)
I have given LKQ ample time to offer a remediation and apology which they refused, so this is how I’m going to handle things. 4/29/24 I was on my way to work in Big Flats, NY on my motorcycle. I was in the passing lane by the mall and Walmart in Horseheads when I was passing an LKQ truck. The LKQ truck came up hot on someone in front of them so they ran me out of my lane almost hitting me. They saw me as they were watching me attempt to pass. It’s not like I was blending in, but they were blatantly NOT paying attention to the road and watching me instead. I was ran off the road into the median on 17 east. They got off at the mall exit right behind me to fill up at the same speedway I went to across from the mall. No “I’m sorry” or apology or anything. Just smug and dirty looks. I contacted LKQ many times to at least get an apology and they won’t even give me that.
My friends, you should really shop around. They wanted $2400 for a remanufactured transmission. I found one that was not remanufactured but rebuilt under 40000 miles. For $800. And the gentleman even threw in the fluids I needed.
I have been doing business with them for years, When they restructured their phones and call center i am constantly on hold for over 15 minutes now. Parts are good but the service is not
What a fantastic find. Got what I needed with professional advice an insight, direct from the locatiion GM. Best part was I paid wholesaler price for certified aftermarket parts.
A little more expensive than what the lkq site told me (for my part specifically, don't know if it's a trend) but they have next day delivery for most any part they don't have, which is nice because I no longer have to spend $30 and several hours in the car to go someplace else. Everyone is kind and they have a "no hassle" return policy. It's a good place
2374 Chili Ave, Rochester, NYBottle & can redemption center
Website
