This rating is based on customer reviews, inventory size, pricing, and service quality
The Good Old Motorcycle Parts Company in Jersey City, NJ draws polarized reviews: strong praise for rare vintage/Harley inventory, accurate parts (incl. custom OEM harnesses) and fast shipping—even overseas—contrasted by repeated reports of rude phone interactions and unhelpfulness. Several note it’s not a public storefront, which can frustrate drop-ins. Pros: selection, follow-through, quick turnaround. Cons: customer service varies sharply; help matching parts may be refused; pricing rarely noted. Overall: 62/100. Score reflects the provided reviews only.
Address:
430 Communipaw Ave B3A3, Jersey City, NJ, United States
What clients say about The Good Old Motorcycle Parts Company in Jersey City (NJ)
If you are a professional, this is the best place to go for Vintage Harley transmission parts. I’ve used a few of their kits over the years and they are thorough and of good quality. They take the time to itemize, stock, and ship almost anything you could possibly need for a transmission repair. A+++
Called looking for parts. Guy on the phone was very rude and sounded mad that I was looking for parts , I would not recommend dealing with this company, accused me of thinking he was a scrap dealer, was he calling my bike scrap ? I want new parts!!
Bob was extremely helpful. He went out of his way to make sure I had the correct parts for my current build and followed through on everything he said. They won a customer for life. Thanks Bob and Bean.
Purchased the perfect handlebars for my 1948 EL, a Top Quality item. This original lookalike is only available in very few places, if not only in this one place.
Top Service too, Bob communicates very clearly, does what he promises and better.
The handlebars took 2 weeks to arrive in The Netherlands, that's pretty swift, all went well!
A highly recommended place to get your parts from!
i needed a few parts for a1996 hd and they had the parts. they sent them right away & were good parts. also sent me 2 company decals that are outstanding, thanks good old boys!!
I needed a complete wiring harness for my ‘92 Sporty 1200 and all I could find was aftermarket (which I was not trusting my electrical system to that ).) Until I found TGOMC...they didn’t have one ready but they built me an OEM harness and had it to me in less than a week after I placed the order! They were also personable and friendly! I would recommend them to anyone with an older Harley needing major wiring work!
I am a Big Fan!
Requested assistance to order the correct pipes for a particular model Harley and was told that what is on the website is what is available. Bob didn't want to "play this game". I just wanted to order the correct parts. So unhelpful.
**EDIT TO ADD - yes, sometimes we deal with losers and you are one of them.
These guys are first rate and a pleasure to deal with. They go out of their way to deliver exceptional service. I rate them 100%+ on integrity and helpfulness. Great work guys
This is NOT a "public" store... or even a visible storefront. When I arrived, I called and they asked me if I have a Harley or an Indian. I don't, and I guess that's required before they'll reveal their secret location! Whatever!
881 Communipaw Ave, Jersey City, NJUsed car dealer
Website
