Yoder's Fresh Market in
Lake Sarasota (FL)

I used to like Yoder's, but their prices have gotten to be ridiculous.

I enjoy coming here to eat lunch! The chicken salad cranberry sandwich will fill you up and somehow make you want more at the same time.

The Amish community gem, all homemade goods.

Little store with a great selection of Amish foods including amazing bakery items. They also have grab and go meals from Yoder's restaurant next door and fresh made sandwiches if your are looking for a quick meal.

Phenomenal coffee, lots of options for sugar free syrups, and delicious pies. The staff is friendly and the market is clean and well stocked.

Yoder’s Fresh Market is such a charming place and an experience in itself. The moment we walked in, the atmosphere felt warm and welcoming—like a throwback to a time when everything was made from scratch with love and care. The market was spotless and beautifully arranged, with shelves full of fresh fruits, homemade goods, and unique items you just don’t find in a regular grocery store. What really stood out was the selection of desserts and prepared foods. The pies alone are worth the visit—beautifully made and hard to resist. There were flavors like peanut butter cream, butterscotch, strawberry, coconut, and more, each looking like it could be the best dessert you’ve ever had. You could literally taste the freshness just by the way they looked. The hot food section smelled amazing with options like fried chicken, grilled garlic chicken, homestyle mashed potatoes, and classic sides that made your mouth water just walking by. Everything looked hearty, fresh, and homemade. Whether you’re craving comfort food or sweet treats, Yoder’s Fresh Market is definitely a place you’ll want to come back to again and again.

We ordered a bunch of items but will only highlight the best ones. The cinnamon roll, oatmeal raisin cookies, pecan pie bar & the jar of peaches were all excellent. So good! ?

After enjoying a hearty meal at the Restaurant, we wandered next door to Yoder's Fresh Market, which carries groceries, country store staples, a deli counter, specialty items and more. We jumped at the chance to take home some coffee grounds, peanut butter cup buckeyes, Dew with real sugar (!) and a few other treats that caught our eye. If you missed the pies in the restaurant, here's your chance to take some home. Fast and friendly service mixed with reliable kitchen staples and unique offerings make this a can't-miss stop on your way thru town. A coffee shop addition is planned and coming soon.

Yoder’s Fresh Market is always a pleasant market to visit. The variety of all the Amish foods is spectacular!! It is a very inviting place fully stocked from fresh produce, baked goods, refrigerated food, jams, juices and just about everything Amish. The staff are very friendly and helpful as well. The outside has nice murals painted on the garage doors with beautiful flowers outside in planters. I’ve been here before and I’m always looking forward to stopping by when I’m in the area.

Excellent Pennsylvania Dutch food including jams/jelly, pies and other deserts, breads, soups and excellent prepared foods such as beef stroganoff and meatloaf and potatoes, cold cuts and much more. Open every day except Sunday and there is perking. Friendly and helpful staff.

I stop here at least once a week,it's perfect after hard day of work to pop in and get a home cooked meal to go and stock up on yummy desserts,I also like to get a tub of their tuna fish salad to eat for lunch during the week..( inside tip) the very back cooler has a kinds of yummies marked half off make sure you check it during your visit.

I love browsing the market which offers an abundance of products from homemade prepared foods, jams, breads, desserts, candies, cookies to memorabilia items plus more. As I stroll the aisle l admit l cannot pass up their chicken salad and in my basket it goes!! Treat yourself to browsing in the market after enjoying your meal!

Awesome little market in sarasota. The people are always friendly and helpful, and the products are fresh, taste great, and they have a good variety. I love the sandwiches they make to order, as well as the refrigerated breakfast sandwiches are great for early mornings.

I just adore this place. Fresh produce and baked goods that are delicious. Chicken salad, soups, cookies etc. All made fresh and have never disappointed. I travel here as much as possible from Tarpon and visit all the local stores. Very relaxing place and the staff are so nice.

Wow! Never been here before. Great selection and service. Can’t wait to come back.

My extended family members talked about their annual trip over to Sarasota for years. I decided to meet them....We met at Yoders what a pleasant and wonderful place. Picked up a few items at the gift shop, walked over to the market and they ordered goodies to take home and deliver to neighbors/family. We had lunch and it was really good The staff are so kind, pleasant and friendly. We all got something different, everything was tasty. Hard to find restaurants that cook liver, (something you eat at home, lol) yep they did and it was good. They even had humming bird cake, it was good. They're portions are large so, I had food and dessert to take home. If you're passing through Sarasota, take a little time and stop by Yoders. I had never been to an Amish community before, it was a pleasant day.

They have everything. I wanted to eat everything. Staff was friendly.

Good Amish-type foods. Drinks. Fresh fruits and veggies. Great selection.

If I wasn't from out of town I would be here everyday I loved all the fresh vegetables and fruits and canned items. And I highly recommend the horseradish cheese.

Great selection of fresh veggies and fruits at a great price. Very clean and well stocked. Nice selection of homemade canned products too.

Wish they had more fresh bread options. Other than that it was a really neat market. I did get a fresh loaf and some watermelon jam.

Wow this place has all the fresh stuff you could want. From amazing cookies to fresh fruits and vegetables. Plus they have a whole section of prepared foods. We are from Pa near the Amish country and this place rivals them. We will be back.

Not what I expected... very nice place to visit. Great for tourists and visitors. I didn't see bulk items (50lb sacks of rice, beans, grains, flours,etc.)

Great food! Pies are wonderful! The Birch Beer is so fun!

This is a great place to shop. We bought some amazing items. Everything from fresh produce to cheese, butter, syrup, pancakes mix.... I recommend this shop highly.

Fresh beautifully displayed fruits, vegetables, breads and snack foods. So many good foods and at very reasonable prices.

We buy most all of our produce here - and a lot of other things - try to Amish popcorn (medium hulless) - pop it in one of those new silicone microwave poppers!