XTRA CHANGE OF MAHOPAC, INC. (BUY•SELL•TRADE) in
Mahopac (NY)

This place is awesome! Louie is a great guy well knowledgeable and very fair priced to buy and sell, always gives me a great deal wether I’m buying or selling something 5 stars across the board I wouldn’t go anywhere else

Great place. Lou is knowledgeable and polite. Great place to try for toys and other unique items. New stuff everytime I stop by.

I love my Louis Vuitton overnight bag. It was in such great condition and at a fraction of the retail price. If you like designer purses, I highly recommend Xtra Change in Mahopac.

This shop is mighty! As a toy collector, I always walk away with awesome finds ?. He also has a wide range of unique treasures such as trading cards, tools, and jewelry. There are very few shops like this in the area. The owner Louie is an amazing guy and loves The LORD. If you love the thrill of the hunt (of collectibles), and the support of small businesses, show XTRA CHANGE some love ❤️

Louie is one of the most honest, business men I know. I have been shopping and doing business at his establishments from day1. My kids love going in and looking for a hidden treasure, or something you’ve been looking all over for and boom there it is , casually sitting on a shelf, I 99.9% leave empty handed…or he’s alaways giving the kids something as a kind gesture … I would recommend this business and Louie to anyone ..friends and family alike. A good local business that everyone should support! All the best!

XTRA CHANGE in Mahopac is an absolute treasure trove! Louie is a standout — always helpful, genuine, and welcoming. His friendly vibe turns every visit into something special. The shop is filled with unexpected gems that you’ll want to explore and take home. It’s the kind of place where browsing becomes an experience — and yes, you’ll probably spend more than you planned! If you're looking for a welcoming spot with great service, fair deals, and a collection of cool treasures, this is it. Highly recommend dropping in — it’s a visit you’ll enjoy every time.

Been coming here for 4 years and its always a pleasant experience. Lou always gives very fair deals on everything. Highly recommend visiting his store for buy/trade!

The least knowledgeable place when it comes to vintage designer, quality, pricing and authenticity.. these guys definitely need to study up more before continuing business and taking money from People

I recently visited Xtra Change and was very pleased. Louie and his staff were very knowledgeable and helpful. They helped me pick out the perfect items. Will definitely be back .

Amazing store with a wide range of cool and unique items as well as cards + collectibles! Awesome staff, super friendly and easy going people. Highly recommend if you're in the area. These guys know how to make you happy!

Stopped by for the first time about 10 days ago and was thoroughly impressed. Louie and his staff were a pleasure to work with. They are personable and knowledgeable. Selection was good with a wide range of tools, collectibles, etc to choose from. Definitely will be going back. Went back this past week and made a trade and it really felt like both side came out a winner!

I recently visited xtra change and was thoroughly impressed! The store offers a fantastic variety of high-quality collectibles. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable, making the shopping experience enjoyable. Prices are fair, with great deals on both buying and selling. The store is clean, organized, and promotes sustainable shopping.

The XTRA CHANGE is honestly such a cool place to visit and check out. There’s an impressive amount of stuff ranging all the way from power tools to video games, memorabilia, collectible figurines, all good stuff. The owner Louie is really kind and it’s always a pleasure to go into that store.

Stumbled across this place and decided to take a walk inside. Spent about 10 min with the owner Louie talking about a few different items he had. I showed him a picture of a Fender Vintera II in Lake Placid Blue, and he offered me about 15% more than 4 other shops! I've since bought and sold numerous items with Louie and have never felt that I was on the losing end of any deal we made. If you're looking for an HONEST shop that won't try to shake you down, then this is the place.

Awesome store with awesome stuff. The owner is very professional and knowledgeable. He always helps me Out with pricing and understanding the products and their worth . He takes the time with each person to hear what they are looking for. Very fair and balanced. There has been many times where I will contact him about a certain item and he will direct me where to go. So many cool things in the store as well.

My family & I have been shopping at XTRA CHANGE for years & we love it! There is always something for everyone & a special unique gift for every occasion. We have brought home such beautiful treasures over the years & some sentimental holiday pieces that you just couldn’t find anywhere else. From new, to pre loved, vintage & rare items, There’s always cool things to check out! So many holiday gifts came from here that were given and received & LOVED. Louie & his family are so warm, welcoming & truly make you feel like a part of their own family. If you’re looking to find a special gift for someone, a unique piece for your home & something you can treasure for the years to come, I recommend stopping in to the XTRA CHANGE, it’ll become your go to place to shop.

Lots of hidden Gems. This is not like your normal Pawn shop that everything is behind a glass wall. You can walk around and browse. He has a huge selection from collectables to modern items. I got lost in the selection multiple times. Very organized as well. Great prices. The owner has a great and nice attitude. Definitely will be coming regularly to find any hidden gems.

Xtra change in Mahopac is greet spot To find something. He always has cool stuff and such a mixture of items to look at. The owner, Lou, is approachable and knowledgeable in many different fields. I haven’t sold anything to him personally but have been there countless times listening to him and. Customers interact and the customer always seem to leave happy, satisfied and with one less thing then what they walked in with lol. If you’re looking for something different and unique for a gift or yourself def check this place out. I personally have purchased two items here that made people very happy.amd the prices were excellent. Best around no doubt.

Such a gem to have in our area! Always has a different choice of surprises to choose from. The owner, Louie knows everything about his stock and loves to give recommendations, whether it be for a gift or something for yourself. I try to get there as much as possible to see what’s new.

Great spot ! Always gotten great classic gaming things in working condition, vintage lighters , graded comics , and graded baseball cards , some 14k rings. Never had an issue with authenticity here with any of the items I’ve bought. Feels like they take that extra step to make sure they sell reputable merchandise. Always new things every time i go

I went in to sell an iPad and Louie gave me a very good offer! He was extremely professional and courteous. Very friendly. They have an awesome selection of sports memorabilia, tools and a ton of other collectibles. If you’re in the area and looking for a great gift, stop by! You won’t be disappointed with the selection they have to offer. 10/10 would recommend!

Louie is a straight shooter. Good business. I got 3 local opinions on some items, and he came in the highest. Even the items I had that weren't in his wheel house, he offered me some guidance on where to go and what to expect to get for them. Everything he said ended up checking out. I will definitely go back.

I have always had a pleasant experience at Xtra Change! Louie is very accommodating, and stands behind the items he sells. His offers for my items are always fair as well. My family has been going to The Xtra Change for years! Highly recommend!

I usually don’t go by reviews. I always feel you should check out a business for yourself. Mainly because some reviews aren’t the truth. Some are competition and some get paid for writing reviews. But I felt I needed to write one. Since the Xtra Change opened I always felt very comfortable going into the store. I would have things that I wanted to sell and the Owner Louie made me feel very well welcomed. Even if I wanted to see how much something was worth , I knew Louie would be honest with me and tell me the truth. Sometimes we think we had hidden gold but it doesn’t work out like that. If anyone wanted to sell their gold or hidden treasures please go and see Louie at the Xtra Change. You will not be disappointed. Truly a little gem store in the heart of Mahopac.

I have bought and sold items with Louie since the start of his business. He is the nicest, fairest and kindest person I know and has the greatest merchandise. Love Louie and his XTRA CHANGE!!!!

I went into xtra change with some jewellery i wanted to see if it was worth anything . Louie was very patient with me, he was very kind and honest ! He let me make my own decisions without any pressure and gave me a few different generous options as to what i could do with the jewellery . Besides Louie being such a wonderful person he has a ton of variety of items to choose from all affordable and good condition! Great place to shop for quality and unique gifts on a budget !

I have only had extremely positive experiences with Louie at thextrachange store in mahopac, NY. The store is great and there are always new and exciting items that Louie has for you! He has helped me out a great deal, and he is extremely fair with his pricings. I have nothing but positive things to say about louie, along with his store!