What clients say about Staria Automotive in Selden (NY)
Brought them my car to do the front and rear valve cover gaskets, but I tried to save myself money and bought the gaskets myself, Durlast from Autozone.
Well, I screwed myself doing that, and they screwed me too. They didn’t put it back together properly and now, less than a year later, they expect me to pay for it again.
I brought it back in and they slapped some sealant on it, put it together properly and told me thats all they can do, and to come back to get it redone and they’ll charge me.
I am furious! I have been coming here for YEARS and have had no issues, now they cant put the engine back together properly! Am I supposed to check every job they do, that they did it right? Aren’t they the mechanics??
I am a single mom working 3 jobs and the oil leaked all over my starter AND my alternator that I just replaced a year ago!!!
Now my car broke down in the middle of winter and Im left with nothing.
Im scraping pennies together meanwhile they're nickel and diming me.
DO NOT GO HERE! Especially if you're looking for a job well done!!!
Was recommend by the great guys at Autoland USA, they were very accommodating and very friendly. They were able to get me in and out quickly despite the fact they were very busy. The prices are fair and reasonable. They also do warranty work. This is a real auto mechanic shop not some flashy chain. Would highly recommend.
Outstanding Service at Staria Automotive – Honest, Reliable, and Highly Recommended
I’ve been using Staria Automotive for my vehicle repairs for years, and they’ve consistently gone above and beyond. Every time I bring my car in, they are honest, efficient, and never try to upsell me unnecessary work. They simply fix what needs to be fixed — nothing more, nothing less.
A couple of months ago, I had a catastrophic engine failure on the LIE — a rod went straight through the engine block. Thankfully, I had warranty coverage, but it still took over a month for the warranty company to approve the repair. Throughout this frustrating process, Staria Automotive was incredible. They stored my Jeep safely for two months, put it on and off the lift multiple times due to incorrect parts, and never once complained or charged me anything extra for the hassle.
Thanks to their persistence and professionalism, I finally got my Jeep back — and it’s running great.
This shop has been around for many years for good reason. They are honest as the day is long, keep you fully informed about your car’s needs, and do fantastic work. I can’t recommend them highly enough for anyone looking for a trustworthy, skilled automotive repair shop.
Staria is amazing, I have been a customer for 22 years and have always had a great experience.
The moment came full circle when my son (who’s on Autism spectrum) found them on Google maps and wanted to visit them as he is currently passionate about automobiles and mechanics shops!
My son made a T-shirt with their logo and we visited and the staff was extremely attentive and kind to us. We took some pics and my son left so happy!!! This is a great group of people, doing amazing work! 👕🚗🧰
A hidden gem! I got there as the shop was opening and there was a line out of the door! These guys were able to help me on a Saturday morning with NO frustration! Will be coming back for all of my car troubles.
I took my car to Staria’s Transmission ‘s, which is owned by Staria’s automotive as per the New York State BBB. They tried to repair my transmission and failed after two years of attempts to rectify the situation. After winning in small claims court, I reached out to Staria Automotive because the transmission shop down the block that they own based on the Better Business Bureau‘s website which was registered under Staria‘s automotive’s address is now closed. I spoke with what I believe was the owner after winning my judgment and he was as rude as ever stating I dealt with the transmission shop deal with the transmission shop. What his inexperienced self does not know is if you register a business under your current business it is that current businesses responsibility if the DBA is no longer in business. He should have registered it as Staria’s Transmission ‘s if he didn’t want this to happen all I am looking for is the $4000 that I paid and I am owed back. The decent thing to do would be for Staria automotive to man up and pay me the 4000 they owe me which was confirmed by Suffolk County Small Claims Court. Hey Staria - You Will Pay Me I Will Get MY Money Back =]
Brought my car in for a few issues, they had an entire week to fix the issues I requested. Go to pick it up and I barely made it out of the parking lot and the traction control light comes on. I want to add that was not one of the issues I gave it to them with, it wasn't an issue at all. I bring it back and they test it with the computer and take it for rides. Turns out in the process of fixing one of the other issues my car had they installed a defective part that caused a whole new issue, I want to mention again they had my car for A WEEK. The guy tells me, " oh you can leave it and we'll fix it next week we are closing for the day." I paid what I thought was a fair price and stupidly expected it to be fixed not have more issues.
Recently I had the pleasure of having my car repaired at Staria. I was on my way to work when I noticed that one of my tires had only 7lbs of air. I went to Staria whom I used in the past many many times. Daryl immediately took my car in and saw that I had a screw in my tire. He had a qualified mechanic repair the tire right away. Daryl was my Superman that day!! Great work & Great guys! Oh and I made it to work on time!!! Thanks for the quick & excellent service!!!!!
Daryl, Paul and the rest of the guys always do a great job! They are honest which is very rare in this business, very nice to see that still exists! I highly recommend them!
Expensive and sloppy work. There is a reason why the manufacturer uses retaining clips and shielding for hoses and lines! You shouldn't just leave this off especially if you're charging a premium!
I never leave reviews but felt the need to because I had such a great experience here. Needed an inspection and was passed and out in literally 10 minutes.
I have been coming here for at least 8 years and have never had an issue. I have referred many people here over the years and I always had good things to say about Staria's; Until today. When I went I didn't see any familiar faces. I spoke to a really nasty gentleman with a attitude. I asked how long was the wait for an inspection because I called ahead and was told there was no line. I got there and there were people ahead that was fine.I said wow saying to my daughter there is three people ahead of us and that was when I was told to go somewhere else if I didn't want to wait . I have been there before and had to wait with 8 cars ahead of me so that wasn't my problem. My problem was not being treated with respect or kindness. I took my service where it's appreciated.
I had my inspection done here for a 2004 Honda Accord and it failed the inspection due to a weak battery, for other shops they charge you $35 for a failed inspection, but not for Staria. My car actually failed twice due to a bad battery and they just told me to buy a new battery and bring it back. These people are nice and honest, hard to find honest mechanics nowadays. Highly recommended!
I always get screwed because I'm a young woman who doesn't know cars. I truly feel comfortable and safe with them. They so far have not tried to steal from me or lied. They are 100% honest and good people. They very much try to work with you to make you happy. I been sending my friends and family to them and everyone has been enjoying this good old mom and pop. Always support small businesses. These are good hard working people and deserve our business.
I can't say thanks enough to Staria Automotive . They are truly incredible and honest. I have been told by 4 different mechanics including the dealer of Ford that I need a new transmission. My car has been down for months almost 14 months to be exact. I took it to a few different transmission shop ,dealer and other mechanics ,only to be told I need a new transmission. Staria transmission took a look at it and then send me over to Staria automotive. I was surprised with the news after their inspection. It turn out I didn't need a transmission after all. They save me alot, thank you guys so much . ❤️
My car is a 2013 Ford escape for review purposes only.
I used Staria for the first time this week on a recommendation from a friend. Very happy with them! I hope that I don't have any future car issues, but if I do - this is the place I'm taking my car to.
In a world of sketchy mechanics these guys rise above the rest. It was very clear they weren't trying to milk repairs for more money. They were also super helpful in regard to explaining what was going on with my car and ALL of my options. I highly recommend them.
Awesome service from the beginning! Always very nice when you call! they definitely take their time to make sure that their customers leave satisfied and I always do! I have gotten an oils change, rear brakes and pads on my car with 0 issues and all done at a great price! I will be bringing my car back for all future maintenance and repairs! Thank you Daryl & crew at Staria Automotive 👍🏼
We bring all our cars here. They are great at what they do! I highly recommend using this company. As a woman it is important to have a trustworthy mechanic. Daryl is always friendly and helpful.
The best repair shop on Long Island. You can trust that you won't get ripped off especially if you are a woman. Honest guys indeed. You will never beat their prices. Actually cheaper bc they want repeat customers. My mechanics for over 25 years! Paul the owner is a genuine human being. All Good Guys. They know how to handle Warranty & Insurance inspectors too. G0! You will be happy you did & for sure keep coming back.
This is my go to mechanic. As a woman, I never feel like they are trying to take advantage and sell me repairs I don't need. They are honest, reliable and excellent mechanics. You can be sure your vehicle is fixed correctly. Will go no place else.
My experience with Staria has been nothing but positive. Everyone who works there is extremely polite and patient. I've seen the kind of craziness they deal with while waiting for my car and I give them a ton of credit for how they handle it. Even when my car needed specialty work through a dealership, they were super helpful and accommodating with the towing process. Trustworthy, reliable, and prompt every time I've gone to them. I highly recommend them and I'm thankful they're my local shop.
Have been a customer for over 25 years. Always satisfied with the price & the work. Always truth. They've never failed me. I'm moving out of state & wanted to leave this review before going. You can trust Daryl & Paul to good a great job & be totally honest.
They fixed the wheel bearing on my car and now no more grinding noise and car rides super smooth. Pricing was reasonable and they even used the parts that I supplied.
What a great place. Honest and affordable. I trust them and trust that they will take care of everyone that I recommend. It’s hard to find a mechanic that you can trust but they make it easy. Make sure you ask for Darrel or Paul. Great guys!
I've been going to them for about 15 years (with two cars for ten of those years.) There was only one time that the problem wasn't fully fixed and they honored their repair. Fixed at no charge.
I got a new car a few years back and was covered under the warranty until last year. I went to a place that was slightly more convenient to go to and regretted it.
Took it to Staria. In and out with no problem.
Four stars because the waiting room ain't so hot. Otherwise it would be five. I go out of my way to bring my car there now.
I have been a customer with Staria Automotive for over 25 years. I have found the owners to be fair and reasonable, and they get the job done quickly. I have no hesitation in recommending them, the repairs are done correctly and I find that my cars have been taken care of with expertise.
Website
