This rating is based on customer reviews, inventory size, pricing, and service quality
In Dallastown, PA, THE TIRE PLACE LLC scores 91/100 with largely glowing feedback. Reviewers highlight friendly, knowledgeable techs, integrity (fixing when possible), great prices, and fast service—often same-day and quick in/out. Inventory spans new and used tires; staff can source matches and often have common sizes in stock. As a small shop, waits can occur. Weak spots are rare but notable: reports of wheel-stud damage, scratched aftermarket rims, missing valve caps, and one unresolved defective set/sensor issue. Little noted about yard organization or parts lookup.
What clients say about THE TIRE PLACE LLC in Dallastown (PA)
Took my tire in from my Chevy Trailboss to see if they could salvage it with a gapping hole in the tread. They did! Saved me tons of $ and quickly had it repaired. A++ for price and service they gave me, couldn't be happier!
The customer service was great. Did what they said they would. Price was fair. Let me drive these tires to and from BWI on Friday and I'll complete this review.
I went to get new tires, they put the tires on, and they broke three Dorman wheel studs, but they only admitted to breaking one. If you don't want to pay for something and then have them break something else, don't go to that place because they won't take responsibility for it.
I'd give more stars if I could. The main guy that runs this place took the time and informed myself that I didn't need a whole new used tire because it only had a hole in the middle of my tire. He said he could plug it and even showed myself where the fix a flat was coming out of. That alone saved myself even more $. When your on fixed income even little bit helps! Note for owners, please advertise more and I believe you guys will definitely get more business. I learned of this place by word of mouth. I lived in the RL area all my life and never knew this place was even here. Now a week later I purchased a new used vehicle and when I need tires for it I will be calling them to order the ones I want. Highly recommend this place and it's supporting local business. A+ guys
The guys that work at The Tire Place were very nice. They did a great job on putting my new tire on they mounted and balance them. I was in and out in no time. I will definitely go there again. Thanks so much.
Bought 4 tires and had problems with them for months right from the beginning. Had to keep taking the car back because of bouncing and wobbling. Had to buy new nuts twice. Tires were defective and they did nothing to take care of the problem. They kept coming up with lame excuses about why we continue to have problems. We're told that they did not have sensors which they actually did. Kept having indicator lights going on for tire problems Ended up going to a name brand National Tire Dealer and they said too bad for you. You got snookered. In other words, ripped off.
Very nice guys and the service was amazing and now to say the tire price i got you can't beat it for new tires I will be recommending them to family and friends
The Tire Place was awesome. Incredibly helpful and friendly staff who found the slow leak in my tire and repaired it ASAP. They made sure I was able to continue with my road trip.
Great place to get your tires fixed. Great prices. The guys that work there are so polite. Definitely going back there next time I have tire problems. I would also definitely buy my next set of tires there.
The people were nice. But they scratched 3 of my brand new $1200 wheels when putting on my new tires. Be careful. DO NOT go here if you have aftermarket wheels.
Had a tire fail and was not ready to buy a full set of tires. They had a used tire that matched pretty closely and mounted, balanced and disposed of the old tire for $64. This was for a 275/60R20 tire. Replaced it while I waited. Great place to deal with.
Newer to the area, I wasn't sure where to go. Tire Place was recommended. I arrived an hour early and they got me right in, 40 mins later I was out the door. I got good tires at a great price. The gentleman even put toddler learning on the TV for my son. Will come back and recommend to others!
I went to the " Tire Place" when they first opened and i continue to go there.They have great customer service and they go out of their way to make sure that you are completely satisified.. I NEVER had a problem with any of their tires new or used like i have with other local tire places. I highly recommend them.
I’ve brung my car here a couple times and i’ve always received fast and friendly service but today was exceptional, i’ve never had a complete stranger in the auto business ever be so relaxed in going out of their way to make sure the service was complete and i drove away safely. I was more annoyed with the hassle for them than they were and it was incredibly refreshing to do business with people who are genuine and authentic. And although they’re prices are great already, you can’t put a price on the way they treat you..thanks for everything and making me feel beyond secure before leaving!!
I went in to get new tires mounted and balanced on my rims. I called ahead and showed up 5 minutes later. They pulled me into the garage immediately and started. It took probably 40 minutes from the time I got there to leaving. It was a really good price, will go again.
Did go again, same great experience even quicker this time
Had a slow leak a few months ago in my front passenger side tire. Called around to 4 different shops for pricing/timing for an internal patch. 2 shops couldn’t book me until a week or so out (which I couldn’t wait for since the tire would go close to flat in a day and half and it was a pain to keep refilling), another shop told me the only did tire plugs and wouldn’t patch it, and another shop never even called me back. The tire place told me to bring my car in straight away and they got me in and out of there in 45 minutes for around $20. Great service, super fast and really good prices too! It’s definitely my go to now to buy new tires or get a tire repair.
After being told by Penn Tire they didn't have new tires in stock (um, what?) I drove down the street to the tire place. They had them in stock and installed them quickly and I didn't have any issues. When I recently got a flat on 83 I went back here for a new tire. They even put my spare back in my trunk properly for me (underneath the mat). They're really great!
The staff are very helpful and very nice. They were able to get what I needed and they were very fast. The cost is very affordable and they do not try to upsell you on other things. They checked all my tires and gave me their advice on them. Will use them again. They have used and new tires
These guys are fantastic! Twice this month we have had some bad luck with a flat time & a punctured tire on our vehicles, and both times, The Tire Place has gotten us back on the road in under an hour. Very friendly staff & reasonable rates, will absolutely recommend & return when needed.
I have had two solid experiences now with The Tire Place. My most recent visit was just a few days ago - I had called a number of shops in the area looking for same-day work, and all but The Tire Place turned me down.
When I arrived, I was approached by an employee before I could even get to the shop doors to ask how I could be helped. Despite having two other customers there having work performed, I was in, out, and paid within 20 minutes (for work on a single wheel/tire) - very pleased with their prompt attention and hard work.
This is clearly a growing small business - the building is not hyper modern/polished, and they have two garage bays, so their volume is necessarily smaller than some other shops. However, the employees appear to have expertise in their work, and I have always received a good personal experience.
Friendly, helpful, quick and easy. My new favorite spot for tires. They even helped me get a full size spare, and sold me rims in the same brand as my car for under a hundred bucks for three. You can't beat these guys!!
Excellent and honest. I went in expecting to have to buy two new tires and instead, they were able to repair my tires. My tires were about a year old and had excellent tread and lots of life still left on them. They could have sold me new tires, repaired and resold the old ones, but they were honest about being able to fix mine. Integrity goes a long way with me. When I am ready to get four new tires, I will definitely be going back there.
Definitely better than any other tire place around. Reasonable prices, and great customer service. Way better than Penn Tire Exchange, which my dad use to take me to ever since I started driving. But their business has gone down hill in the last few years.
Website
