Time Warp Toys & Collectibles in
Lake Grove (NY)

Very upset I’m a daily customer with this toy store. I go in to purchase an item talk to one of the workers come to a deal. I take the item to the register to go purchase it. Unfortunately, the other worker says a lady over the phone, wants it in my opinion this is very bad business on their part first come first serve and for someone that’s an everyday customer. I’ve given these people a lot of business and I will never go back there again after this.

I love going to this place but I have been asking about something that I want to get and I’ve been asking for a year and still nothing.

Not only is it a retro toy store but there are other vendors in there! Over 25! Sports cards, jewelry, vintage collectibles, clothing, vinyl, handmade items.....most non toy vendors are to the right side of the store. Its amazing! You gotta go!

Took Elvis itiems in for offer the employee offered a ammount and said come back if you want , called store they explained they dont want it no more but were helpfull trying to give me places to sell it, i wouldnt recmend any verbal deal with this store ....but its a very nice store. any deal you get make sure its in writting !

Love bringing my family here. This is the best place if you want to see toys and pop culture that you grew up with. Being able to show my kids how it felt to shop at a toy store when I was younger is a great experience.

This is the best place for vintage or rare toys and collectibles has a nice horror section the store is laid out with easy to find departments! When ever we are NY we stop in and the new location (next door to the old one same parking lot and all) is HUGE and packed with goodies wall to walll floor to ceiling! Thank you again from your so flo friends Renee and Zane!

Time Warp has everything of vintage toys. The list is endless.Check out this store and buy the collectible things.It is for adults and children and grand children.It is like going on a treasure hunt fun to find unique things.You will love it and keep coming back.The employees are very professional, friendly,

STANDARD CCG inside time warp is An awesome TCG and collectibles spot. Always greeted with a smile and pos vibes. Fun place to take the kids & fam to shop for vintage and new Pokemon goodies and other retro collectibles. From TCG with a great variety for all collectors at fair prices, to 3D print toys, Chris and Alex have created a great spot for the community to shop and come together. Nice spot with a great STANDARD for those who enjoy the hobby.

Absolutely love this local trading card shop! The selection is fantastic, with a wide variety of collectible cards that cater to both casual fans and serious collectors. The staff (Chris & Alex) are incredibly knowledgeable and always ready to help, providing valuable insights and recommendations. I appreciate the friendly atmosphere and the events they host, which bring the community together. Whether you’re looking to buy, sell, or trade, this shop has everything you need. Highly recommend checking it out!

Great store. Lotta cool retro stuff. Standard is my fav department in the whole store. As a big pokemon card guy I’m a huge fan of standards product. Additionally Chris and Alex are two of the nicest sales people I’ve ever met. Pokémon cards are bigger now than ever and unfortunately there are a lot of people who take advantage of others financially because of the popular and valuable product. However Chris and Alex always provide a great and friendly environment and all their prices are way more than fair. They are not scalpers but are quite the opposite actually. They always have a great selection of hits in their booth. My brother and I have made many purchases through them and they have made us a great deal everytime. I love Pokémon cards and always have and I’m so thankful that there are good people in the hobby who aren’t up charging at ridiculous prices. Other Pokémon card sections in the timewarp store are not standard. Only purchase pokemon cards from the back right of the store where it says standard other wise your buying scalped and potentially resealed product.

Chris and Alex are top tier? best place to buy, sell and trade Pokemon tcg. Check out Alex’s Pokemon figures and designs ! Awesome stuff. 10/10 every time I stop in.

Pretty neat place with a lot of stuff to look at. However I was a little disappointed with the movies. I collect films on Blu ray and noticed there was a ton of DVD's only with SOME blu rays sprinkled in. However when I did find some I was interested in, I opened the case to find out that the main disc's were missing. So basically just empty cases, or ones where it just had the DVD copy instead. Oh well. Still a neat store

Fun for a trip down memory lane. Even more fun for your inner child to have a shot at buying a few things from your childhood. I love taking my kid here and pointing out all the stuff I had when I was his age and him being interested in it too. The only thing that puts you off is the flea market / carny vibe. The dank smell of nostalgia comes with the experience.

This is my go-to spot for any collectibles I am hunting for. I have found most, if not all, of my "Grail pieces" here. The staff is always welcoming and willing to work with me on purchases or to find an item I want. I just found out today that they are moving the store next door to them. This means they are going to have double the space, and I can't imagine what treasures I might find now that their full inventory will be out on display. If you are into collecting or just enjoy going on "Toy Hunts," then you need to check this place out.

Took the 2hr ride to here, and well worth it! They have tons of retro toys and figures. A bit of everything for all toy collectors. They owners and staff are very knowledgeable and helpful.

I love this place I really do, been buying ever since their sun vet mall days. The staff is nice just the lady in there only seems to give off a miserable vibe, she seems to only be happy or talkative when you're purchasing something and she does make me not feel wanted sometimes which is why I haven't stopped by often like I used to but the other workers are friendly and chill. Last time I went in there though I was charged like an extra $8.50 for a 40 dollar item which has never happened to me and I always pay cash so I felt that was weird, I understand if I paid with card but I paid with cash. Overall an amazing store if you're looking for hard to find collectables.

This place is real cool if you are looking to collect going back in time. The people there awesome. Won't be disappointed. Anywhere from diecast cars to comics to wrestling sports. Mention Ray sent you

This place is a destination for those who collect cool stuff. Autographs, memorabilia, vintage toys, vintage video games, varieties of weaponry!! Can't go wrong. Totally amazing. Allow yourself plenty of foraging time. There is just so much to discover. All the stuff you lost or broke as a kid are there!!!! Get it all back again!!! Dude, they had a WIDE variety of Garbage Pail Kids!!!!

I was our with my wife and daughter and passed by Time Warp Toys and Collectibles. Having some spare time, I made a quick u-turn and went in. This store is definitely like stepping into a time warp. Here I can find the toys of my childhood. I almost walked out with the Castle Grayskull in my photo! This place was packed with items from the 60's, 70's, 80's and 90's. I came across record players, vintage game consoles, vintage comics and very old decor. If you are in the area I suggest you spend some time here. It's hard to walk out without having made a purchase.

So I’ve been going to these guys since they were in Sun vet mall. This crew really knows how to put together a unique vintage toy store. Everything you could possibly want from Furbies to Voltron! A wide selection, and a very knowledgeable staff. Met two of the owners a few years back, and became good friends with them over the years. So happy they moved into this new location so they can expand their incredible line of collectibles. They work fairly well if everyone that walks through the door and always do right by me. I was reading some of the comments and people are so dramatic, some of you need to go get a hug. I don’t know what is your problem lol. needless to say, check out Time Warp and bring back some of your childhood memories with their wide selection.

This place is huge, has a great location on a main road in a shopping center. It was like walking into Willy wonka and the chocolate factory of action figures! They had a lot of new and older figures, comics, pops etc. I got some Star Wars and McFarlane dc multiverse. They had just about anything you can think of in the world of action figures and the prices are reasonable to the value.

Great store with a lot of variety for fans of all sorts of geek memorabilia from the looks of it! Called to order a figure that my friend told me they had at the store and I wanted to get it shipped . Not the best communication and the guy who ships things out was a little hard to get a hold of and it took them about a week to actually ship it out, but other than that, nice people who have reasonable priced figures.

This store has everything! If you collect anything retro this place has it !! And if he dont he partnered with a guy and right next door they got a bigger collectables/antique/ flea market .

The new Relics market next door was the ballz! So great, i could have spent the whole day there! Awesome store

From my first time coming to this store, I have had nothing short of a great experience. Mike and the rest of the staff are wonderful and provide stellar customer service, the actual inventory is so expansive and remains to this day the only store where I'm continually wowed by the nostalgia of seeing more and more of the toys I loved as a kid. The prices are very fair and when selling to them they do not try and nickel & dime, always offering very fair amounts for what you bring in. Again, all around the best toy collectible store on the island by a mile.

This is an awesome store for fans of vintage toys & comics! They also have a crazy huge selection of Funko Pops if you're into those. I've been there twice now and still haven't seen all there is to notice! Hoping that things I want will still be there next time I go, but this place will get popular, so definitely grab your treasures while you can! I can't wait to see what else they get in :)

So many great pieces in this store. Everything from Gremlins and He-man to wrestling to horror to superheroes to pop culture icons. A few items were even autographed. All products were in good and some great conditions. Pricing was fair. Staff was very personable and friendly. We'll be back.