I have lived here in Mahopac for 20+ years, this was the first time I visited Tilly's table for dinner. We enjoyed it immensely and will definitely be going back?????
Two of our party of three had been there before and had had good experiences, but this visit was disappointing.
All three at our table are GF, so needed to menu guidance to avoid gluten.
Unfortunately, while our servers were very pleasant and well-intentioned, they were neither knowledgeable nor well trained. After multiple back-and-forths to the kitchen with gluten questions, all three of us settled on the seared scallops. Dishes were poorly executed -- especially for the price point. The seared scallops were not so much seared as steamed. (My guess is that the pan was not hot enough to recover from the addition of three orders of scallops at once.)
There were no GF desserts except for ice cream (yawn), so our birthday celebration ended with a shrug.
This is a place with potential: the venue isnt bad, and the staff are eager to please. Not sure whether this was an off night, but won't rush back.
? A Fairytale Wedding at Tilly Foster Farm ?
My son’s wedding at Tilly Foster was nothing short of enchanting. From the moment Carlie arrived in a horse and carriage — a breathtaking entrance that felt straight out of a storybook — we knew we were in for a special evening.
The entire celebration flowed effortlessly. The night flew by in a blur of laughter, love, and unforgettable moments, and thanks to Megan and her outstanding team, we were able to soak it all in without a single worry. Every detail was handled with care and professionalism, allowing us to be fully present for one of the most meaningful days of our lives.
Tilly Foster isn’t just a venue — it’s a place where memories are made, magic is real, and love takes center stage. We’re beyond grateful.
* Mr. and Mrs. Jacob Homberg *
My niece, Erin Shaughnessy, had the most beautiful wedding at Tilly Foster Farm. It was truly a magical day. The ceremony took place outdoors surrounded by the farm's natural beauty. It felt like we stepped into a fairytale.
The barn reception was warm and welcoming. Its wooden beams and cozy atmosphere made the evening feel both romantic and festive. The food was outstanding - fresh, flavorful, and plentiful.
The staff was attentive, friendly, and made sure everything ran smoothly. You could see the joy on the faces of the Bride & Groom as they celebrated their love and gave all of us memories to treasure forever.
Tilly Foster Farm is a gem for weddings - charming, inviting, and unforgettable.
A little pricey. Dish portions are a good size but a few chicken and pasta dishes were a little dry and tasteless. It was also very noisy and parking is a hike up a hill. Grounds are nice as it sits on a farm and we will try again in warmer weather
We had our wedding at Tillys on September 2nd 2023. It was such an amazing experience! The staff was so lovely and helpful! The food was great! The venue itself is so beautiful! I wouldn't have changed a thing about that day! I highly recommend Tillys for a wedding! We were even able to take pictures with the animals!
Food was great. Best filet mignon I've ever had. They give you the steak juice to dip the steak in, Yum. Drinks were really good too and the atmosphere was nice.
Family friendly restaurant. Farm is a great quick stop with the kids. Clean and easily accessible farm animal walk. They have a great mature walk around the pond with art along the path. Great place to kill 2 hours with the younger kids.
Breakfast was expensive, waffles were thick and dry, crabcakes didn't taste like crabcakes, omelets was tasteless and overcooked. Won't be returning. Very disappointing for a farm-to-table restaurant. Would have been better off at the local diner
Beautiful place was here for dinner at a wedding reception cocktail hour area was small but food was good they wouldn't let us hang in the bar after the reception they claimed COVID but they let us stay there for cocktail hour -1* atmosphere and service. dinner food was buffet style but surprisingly good. Over all not bad.
Such a beautiful place. We gad our aunts 50th birthday and everything was so beautiful. The food was amazing! The open bar had so many options and all the servers went above and beyond to help everyone. We loved that they gave out kid meals to all the kids. Sooo beautiful. The bathrooms were big and private. Lots of dancing space and overall an amazing experience
This was my first time at Tilly's Table! I was here for a child's birthday party. The food exceeded expectations and the ambiance goes hand in hand with what one would expect with a large country barn. The place is clean with beautiful surroundings. My kids also loved watching the neighboring donkeys.
The place is a perfect even location. The staff is phenomenal and the food was just as great! The place was clean and the staff were very presentable. I would definitely come back for a meal with my family!
Drove by this place many times, did not notice there was a restaurant there.
The rolls were warm, tasty. Calamari and mussels for appetizers didn't last long, very good, different than others.
I had the chicken martini. It was pretty good.
My wife and daughter had the pasta with Manila clams, they loved it.
My son had the Mac and cheese with lobster, said it was awesome.
Lastly, Our guest had the shrimp scampi, she said it was also very good. HUGE shrimp!
We finished off with a candle in a chocolate lava cake for my daughter's birthday.
We all had leftovers, the portions are huge.
Only downside was the flies buzzing around. I said it just added to the effect of eating at a farm to table restaurant.
I'd have no problem recommending this restaurant to anyone.
Great mother's day brunch. Well worthy of 5 stars. Fantastic selection of foods. I do feel compelled to mention one thing. The bacon was barely cooked , almost raw. That should not take away from the overall positive experience though. Everything else was well prepared
Great place to catch an outdoor concert. The unexpected dinner buffet was great and the free hot pretzels hit the spot after a couple of drinks. Can't wait to catch a comedy show at the Funny Farm.
We came here for a special night out. It was a nice evening so we sat outside. Our reservation was handled perfectly. We ordered the pork belly which was out of this world. The Caesar salad was fresh crispy and delicious. The entrees were equally as impressive. The drinks were even strong, and our server was outstanding. What an awesome experience.
Went there for the first time for a cover band concert. All the concession stands and food trucks were awesome! Everyone was pleasant, food and drinks were great.... as was the band. Parking was easy and well organized.
There were as incident that didn't involve Tilly that I wasn't pleased about while at the concert. If the owner would like to message me privately that would be ok.
We had a great time. We seen Almost Queen and they were good.
Parking was good and they had shuttle buses to get you to concert area.
Trying to get food was a pain lines were really long.
The only main issue I would say was sound.
We were only a 1/3 of the way up hill from stage and at times couldn't hear them singing.
Additional speakers located further back would be great.
Going there Thursday for dinner will update then also.
I've eaten there on 3 occasions, experiencing lunch and dinner. The service is friendly. The prime rib special and the pesce di mar were tasty and cooked perfectly. I was happy to have leftovers! We also enjoyed the field of art that was displayed all season.
Tilly's Table is great fresh food in a country kitchen setting. Humble and so very satisfying. Brunch is a great value. The french toast was delicious and the 8oz NY strip steak and eggs was a dinner meal. Mimosas, coffee were great. Huge fresh buffet table with bagels to fresh green salad. Totally great meal. The animals on display are wonderful. Alpacas! Two beautiful huge black horses and even furry pigs. Great for friends and families with children. Handicapped assessable location. Go, enjoy, eat big and take in the great scenery.
Sunday brunch at Tilly's is nothing short of amazing. Greeted and seated with a warm welcome by the hostess. The buffet table is beautifully presented, offering up a variety of delectable meats, salads, and breads to excite the pallet. Then there's the menu from which you choose amongst several choices made your way, to complete your price fixe brunch. Included is a mamosa or a bloody Mary. All for $29.95 including tax. Tip additional. The 'everything made fresh' food and grand portions won't disappoint. Service with a smile and attentive. The atmosphere is rustic, high ceilings, wood beams, large windows and a towering stone fireplace that makes you feel delightfully relaxed and comfortable. Dinner is also served Thursday thru Sunday night. A very special farm providing great views of rolling hills and post and rail fences. Tilly's Table reminiscent of a time of simplicity.
Website
