Long Island Auto Repair in
Baldwin (NY)

Dropped a car off at eleven with a all in one EBC brake kit from autozone that is known to fit my car..5 star reviews. Shop told me it would be ready by noon. I call them at 12:30 and they tell me the brake pads dont fit from the all in one kit. I've never had this issue before with EBC brake kits specifically designed for a car. Researched it online, and lo and behold....the kit is correct. Guess who has to pay for them taking my car apart and wasting my time?

I’ve supported this shop for years, but my last experience was the final straw. I asked for a simple oil change, and they never asked what type of oil I wanted. They charged me over $80 claiming it was full synthetic, yet put a sticker in my car telling me to come back in 3,000 miles. Full synthetic lasts 7,000–10,000 miles. Either they didn’t use it, or they charged me for something I didn’t get. I also paid for a passenger-side brake caliper replacement, and less than 10 minutes after leaving, my car rolled backward while in PARK. I caught it just in time before it hit another car. When I brought it right back, the mechanic took zero responsibility and told me he’s “not a transmission guy” and to call the police instead of fixing an issue that started the moment they worked on my car. A different shop later confirmed the truth: They left a component near the passenger wheel disconnected, and that’s exactly why the car rolled. It was a simple fix — but a dangerous mistake. I really tried to support this business, but the repeated dishonesty, careless work, and refusal to take accountability make it impossible to trust them. I won’t be returning, and others should be cautious.

I had a noise coming from the front of the car. Took the card to Long Island Auto Repair and they told me that I needed new struts. I had the job done, the noise is gone and the car rides better than it ever has.

It Was My First Time At This Location, I Came In For An Oil Change. It Was The Quickest Oil Change I've Ever Gotten! 100% Recommend

Best auto repair shop in Long Island hands down, best prices,great services, and they’re quick if you want quality work here is the place for you !

Was staying in Hempstead for lax tourney for the weekend, car started sputtering and misfiring, called everywhere in the area, they took it in at 3pm on Saturday and I was on the road back to Syracuse by noon on Sunday. Great service, saved our weekend, can’t thank them enough for their service!

Called for state inspection and easily got in on the same afternoon. They were busy, but very accommodating and got the inspection done in under 2 hours! They didn’t find anything wrong, it’s a new car so that was expected. But they didn’t try to scam me with any unnecessary repairs whatsoever. And at $37 for the whole thing it is so reasonably priced! Highly recommend for your next state inspection.

I couldn’t be happier with the service I received at Long Island auto repair.The staff was honest, professional, and incredibly knowledgeable. They diagnosed the issue quickly, explained everything clearly, and got my car back on the road in no time. No upselling—just straightforward, reliable work at a fair price. It’s hard to find a shop you can trust, but I’ve definitely found mine. Highly recommend to anyone looking for quality auto repairs and excellent customer care!

We moved nearby last year so naturally I was looking for a local mechanic. I’ve been fixing my cars for years but it’s always good to have a spot you can trust when you’re in a pickle. Fair & honest every time. It’s a family business so even better!

Extremely fast. Extremely professional, Very fair and helped me get my van back when everyone else was closed. The ball joint went on my old van and the wheel was hanging off making service on it tough. We'll maybe tough for another repair company. Not these guys. They didn't bat an eyelash and fixed it fast with no drama or stress. The manager was extremely professional and I appreciated the heck.out of him and his staff.

JP at Long Island Auto Repair is by far one of the repair shops I have had the privilege to do business with. He keeps well informed of any repairs you need and don’t need at that time, and his pricing is more than fair. I highly recommend Long Island Auto. 5 out 5.

JP and staff have exactly what you're looking for- honesty, integrity, and transparency. I've used his services countless times, and time and time again they remind me why they are my go to shop. Always happy to do business with genuine people.

Long Island Auto Saved Me Thousands & My Car Runs Like New! I can’t say enough good things about JP and the team at Long Island Auto! I had a serious engine issue that Pep Boys couldn’t figure out. After multiple visits and wasted time, they had no real answers. Frustrated, I took my car to Long Island Auto, and JP diagnosed the problem right away. The dealer quoted me $4,200 for the repair, but JP got it done for less than half that price—and with top-quality work. I was honestly skeptical at first, thinking the car might not hold up, which is why I waited to write this review. But here I am 8 months later, and my car still runs like it’s brand new! If you want honest, expert service at a fair price, Long Island Auto is the place to go. JP truly knows his stuff and doesn’t rip you off like the dealerships. Highly recommend for anyone needing engine repairs, diagnostics, or general auto service!

Came in for a tune-up, inspection, alignment, brakes, and struts on my Jeep, and JP and his team brought it back to life! But the real MVP? Evelyn, the secretary, who has basically become my personal therapist. She made us coffee, listened to me vent, and gave amazing advice—none of which had to do with my car! Great service, great people. If you need top-notch auto repairs and a little life wisdom on the side, Long Island Auto is the place to go!

Long Island Auto – Honest & Reliable Service! Had a fantastic experience at Long Island Auto! JP and his team were professional, quick, and super helpful. I got new tires and a brake check, and everything was done perfectly. Fair pricing, great customer service, and a shop you can trust. If you need tire service, auto repairs, or routine maintenance, JP is the guy to see. Highly recommend!

5-Star Review for Long Island Auto – Best Auto Repair & Tire Service! I had an amazing experience at Long Island Auto! JP and his team went above and beyond to provide top-notch auto repair, tire service, and maintenance for my vehicle. From the moment I walked in, the customer service was outstanding—friendly, professional, and knowledgeable. I needed new tires and a wheel alignment, and JP made sure I got the best deal on high-quality, affordable tires. The service was fast, efficient, and done right the first time. They also performed a brake check and oil change, ensuring my car runs smoothly. If you’re looking for a trusted auto repair shop that offers tire replacements, brake service, oil changes, and general car maintenance, I highly recommend Long Island Auto. JP is honest, reliable, and truly cares about his customers. I’ll definitely be back for all my future car needs! ✅ Great Prices ✅ Fast & Reliable Service ✅ Honest & Knowledgeable Staff Thanks again, JP and team! If you need affordable tires, auto repairs, or routine car maintenance, this is the place to go!

I have to say, my first time coming here I was impressed with the quick response to my arrival. Staff is professional and easy to talk to. JP, the owner, is kind and fair. The service was done to my car with no problem at all! 5/5 recommendation! I sure will be coming back. He took such good care of my BMW. Thank You JP! ?

BEST auto shop on Long Island. I gave this place 5 stars because of the customer service. I came in for two tires, breaks and an inspection which JP helped me with. He ordered the parts i needed which came quickly. The staff was very helpful and answered all my questions. I recommended this place to my friends and family!!, 10/10 recommend and I’ll definitely would be coming back from now on!

JP at the Long Island Auto Repair Shop is the most accommodating person I have met to ensure that your car is fixed and is in even better shape than when it was brought. He cares about his customers and again is accommodating to their times and needs. My family and I go to him every time because we know that we can really count on him for our auto needs!

I own two cars and JP has been amazing. He is extremely knowledgeable and reliable and has assisted during emergency car situations and for regular car maintenance. I know my car is in trusted hands at his shop and there is no one else I will go to for my car needs. Most recently, I heard a ticking noise and he and his team were able to find the root cause. Thank you Long Island Auto Repair! 12/15/23: JP continues to be a trusted mechanic for my husband and I. As a result, I had to add to my review that I wrote previously. I own a 2012 Hyundai Genesis and it has had its fair share of concerns in 2023. When a car presents issue to you, you want to ensure you are working with a mechanic that is trustworthy as well as consultative. At one point, I thought my car was coming to the end of the road. I trusted the advice JP provided to me and we are still going strong 6 months after what I felt was the end. Having a vehicle especially one that is older can be challenging. It is very reassuring to have a mechanic that I can rely and call on and never once feel that I am being taken advantage of. Thank You JP for all you do!

My family and I have been coming to see JP at the shop for the past 4-5 years. His team has worked on a numerous amount of cars just from my family alone. This shop has always been my go to since relocating to long island. The shop is always so welcoming, clean and even has little snacks in the waiting room. 10/10 recommend ! ♡- K

My guys at Long Island auto JP and Marvin always taking care of me great prices and fast work no games played here I bring my family and friends here, highly recommend my guys at Long Island auto

I’ve been coming to the shop since 2018. I’ve had both my vehicles serviced here and I would never go anywhere else. I’ve been to shops where I went in for one problem and I leave with a bill for another or received a run around… I can tell you one thing, that doesn’t happen here. JP not only fixes your vehicle but gives maintenance preventative tips and breaks down the dos and donts to keep your car running smooth. The guys at the shop aren’t in the business to take your money and run they want to make sure your car runs smooth and they make sure your are satisfied. A++

Came in as a walk in and was assisted promptly. Customer service was great, the mechanics were knowledgeable & informative. Clean waiting area, would definitely recommend!

Towed my car there after it didnt start and another shop kept putting parts in and nothing would change. The mechanic with the beard was very informative. He was forthcoming with all the information on my car, and upfront with all the prices that were needed to fix the car. After reluctantly (due to previous experiences elsewhere) putting in the fuel pump that he suggested my car starts runs and drives as promised and was exactly how much i was quoted.

Long Island Auto Repair is one of the best places to bring your vehicle hands down. I have been bringing my cars to JP and the guys for the past 5 years. These guys are extremely trustworthy. They go above and beyond each and every time I visit them. The service is excellent and the pricing is always unbeatable. By far the best shop on the island. I wouldn’t bring my car to any place else. They most definitely have my stamp of approval.

Wow!!! Quick and easy,..JP is awesome mechanic also friendly polite and professional make me feel welcome, they are honest.. very hard to find a honest mechanic!! I will come back!!! For sure. A+++