Reliance Auto Body in
Andover Township (NJ)

I have a mint Audi S4 2012, which had a small accident, but due to bumper parts costing thousands, insurance wanted to total it. Thankfully Mike thought outside the box and fixed the car while making it look cooler than before.

If I could give six stars, I would. I hit a deer and my car was very close to being totaled. Reliance Auto Body was able to bring my car back from the damage it had obtained. From securing all OEM parts, matching the paint perfectly, quick turnaround time, and great communication, saying that this experience was superb is an understatement. I give this establishment a 10 out of 10, and would confidently recommend it to anybody who needs quality service in auto body work. Thank you, Reliance Auto Body!

Excellent service! Mike is the best — he always finds the best prices and the right parts. Very professional, honest, and helpful. Highly recommended!

I was hit head-on back in September 2025 and my car was unfortunately totaled. Out of every car I've ever owned, this was one of my favorites by far (2002 is300). The accident left me with a multitude of health complications and the last thing I needed was to worry about my car (no matter how much I loved it). I really can't thank or recommend Mike and his team enough. He was completely transparent; we talked about my expectations, budget, and all my aftermarket parts that were damaged by the accident before any work began. Not only did they handle everything, and I mean EVERYTHING, but they exceeded my expectations. I'm talking extensive frame repair, rare parts, seamless paint and detail, all ontop of 5 star customer service. You can't find any better, period. Antique, custom paint, brand new vehicle, they knock every single job out the park!

I brought my 1979 Pontiac Firebird to Reliance Auto Body after getting hit so bad I honestly thought the car was done for. It was that close to being totaled. But the team here didn’t just repair it, they brought it back to life in a way I didn’t even think was possible. When I picked it up, I was blown away. The car looks better than it ever has, even compared to before the accident. The body lines are perfect, the paint is spotless, and the whole car has this fresh, clean finish like it just rolled out of a time machine. They didn’t match factory quality, they beat it. This place turned a heartbreaking moment into one of the coolest surprises I’ve ever had as a car owner. You can tell they care about what they do, and they care about the cars they work on. If you’re bringing them something classic or sentimental, trust me, you’re leaving it in the right hands. Super impressed. Super grateful. 100% recommend Reliance Auto Body!!!

I brought my car here after hitting a deer. They gave me a few options to make the repair as affordable as possible but still fixed everything to perfection. You would never know there was any damage, even with a close inspection. The best part is it was done more quickly than expected and much faster than any other shops could promise. I highly recommend!!

I wanted to give a huge shout-out to Mike and Reliance Auto Body in Dover, New Jersey. Our project Beetle is very important to my girlfriend and me, when a family member accidentally grazed the rear quarter panel, we needed a shop we could trust to make it perfect. Mike delivered an absolutely flawless result. He was fantastic to deal with—professional and completely focused on quality. The repair on the rear quarter panel is seamless, and the red paint match is incredible—it looks absolutely great and blends perfectly with the rest of the car. You would never know it was damaged! If you care about your vehicle's finish, especially a beloved project car, Mike and Reliance Auto Body are the only choice. Highly, highly recommend!

I have nothing but great things to say about Reliance Auto Body! Someone swiped my car in a parking lot and unfortunately didn’t stick around to tell me. I took it to Reliance Auto Body and it looks like I just drove it off the showroom floor! The job was done perfectly by Mike and his team, and they did it for a fair price. They returned to my car to me sparkling from inside out. Can’t recommend this place enough :)

I just had my car repaired at Reliance all went very smoothly and it exceeded my expectations. Mike was very easy to work with and even cleaned my entire car it looked showroom new, Ifound his prices to reasonable and I would recommend his services.

Took my car in reliance autobody to get fixed for front-end accident I was surprised how amazing the car cane out super clean and got it back within the same week I dropped it off. The owner was really nice and guaranteed his work. Definitely good honest place in town.

What an AMAZING experience!! I cannot say enough good things about Mike! My car was hit with a flying branch about 24” in diameter. The dent in the roof, creased and chipping paint. It looks brand new!!! He is honest, communicative and did a marvelous job!! Did I use enough exclamation points?!?!? Thank you Mike!!!

We were extremely satisfied with Reliance Auto Body!!!. Mike was polite, professional and competent. My car was returned to me with all the expected repairs perfectly fixed and the car was waxed and cleaned inside as if it was a new car!! The cost was very reasonable. I highly recommend Mike and Reliance Auto Body

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ I had an outstanding experience with Reliance Auto Body Inc in Dover, NJ! From start to finish, their customer service was exceptional—every interaction was friendly, professional, and focused entirely on my needs. The attention to detail on my vehicle was impeccable, and it’s clear that the team takes great pride in the quality of their work. What really stood out to me was their “customer first” attitude—they truly go above and beyond to make sure you’re informed, comfortable, and completely satisfied. Owner Michael Tillero deserves special mention. He’s honest, hands-on, and genuinely cares about doing what’s best for his customers. You can tell he runs his business with integrity and a personal touch that’s rare these days. The pricing was very fair—definitely great value for money considering the level of service and craftsmanship. I highly recommend Reliance Auto Body without any reservations whatsoever. If you’re looking for a body shop that combines expertise with heart, this is the place. ⸻

I had an outstanding experience at Reliance Auto Body ! They recently painted my front bumper and replaced my grille, and the results were flawless—the paint matched perfectly, and the new grille looks great. What really stood out, though, was their professionalism and willingness to go the extra mile. They helped me navigate some tricky insurance issues, which saved me a lot of stress and time. They kept me updated throughout the process and made sure everything was handled smoothly and efficiently. Highly recommend this shop to anyone looking for top-notch bodywork and genuinely helpful service. I’ll definitely be coming back if I ever need work done again. Thanks again to Mike and his team at Reliance Auto Body!

I have been a reliance customer for many years and there’s A reason. Founder Tom Keir has passed the business onto long time employee Mike Tillero and he has continued with the excellent service and quality Most people know reliance for. I whole heartedly recommend reliance for your auto body needs.

Mike was quick with the estimate and the price was very good. The work was done fast and the car looks good as new. Plus they cleaned the car inside and out. We are thrilled. Thank you, Mike

Mike and his team did an amazing job repairing my wife’s Challenger. Matched the paint perfectly, and was done in a reasonable amount of time, considering the work involved. He stood firm with the insurance company and did not back down when they wanted him to cut corners. They have my business for life now. It’s like nothing ever happened 10/10

HANDS DOWN, Mike and his team from reliance auto body are the best auto body shop in Morris county.. I did a full color change from factory forest green to sunset orange metallic…Pictures do this car no justice on my 1991 foxbody mustang notchback… The paint looks like glass!!! They take pride in their craft and go over and beyond for their customers!!! Other shops will leave you with clear coat nibs, fish eyes and paint runs because nobody takes pride in there work!!! You will be a very happy customer when you pick up your car or truck from reliance…

I had a fender bender and took my honda civic touring to Mike and his team. Mike is honest and easy to talk with. He explained everything to me and didn't charge me an arm and a leg. Him and his team got my car fixed in no time. Love how great it looks. Thank you to Mike and the guys.

My Honda was in need of some autobody work, and I had the pleasure of working with the owner of the shop, Mike T. Although he is a new owner, you can tell he is a seasoned veteran to the business. I commend the staff on their excellent customer service, cleanliness, quality work, and efficient turnaround. I highly recommend this shop if you are in need of reliable and reasonable quality services.

Reliance Autobody, owner Mike and his crew, were timely, kind, and thorough when we brought our new car in for an service estimate. We had 3 previous estimates and Mike’s price was reasonable but we chose Reliance because of his wealth of experience and professionalism. Mike did an excellent job on our car which we only had for 3 months. We highly recommend Reliance Autobody on Rte. 15 in Dover!

Super Solid shop bumper came out amazing they also helped me mount my front lip and in a timely manner will definitely be going back for more paintwork soon clean finish

Reliance auto body is the best body shop around. Mike and his team perform amazing work with amazing turn around time and finish product quality. I would not trust anyone else to paint or do body work to my vehicles. Highly recommended reliance auto body for any body work or paint work you are looking to get done. 10/10 work

I highly recommend reliance auto as they were able to fix my car and make it look better than before. I would go here with any of my vehicles or refer them to anyone I know. The staff are all amazing and kind and did amazing work.

I had a spoiler I took to 5 different body shops to paint match for my Gto , I did not want to blend the entire back half of the car , also did not want different shades of candy red in the sunlight , they got it correct on the first try . They have painted several vehicles for me , some we performance related with upgraded spoilers and hoods , and some regular fender benders . All came out great.

I was recommended to Reliance Auto Body by a local mechanic in the area - and I am so pleased that I decided to give them my business. Mike and his team at Reliance Auto Body are professionals and quite amazing at what they do. Mike transformed my scratched up 2009 Honda Pilot into a new car! It looks identical to the day we purchased it. Not only did he do an incredible job, but he is also honest, affordable and easy to work with. Thanks Mike for a great experience. I'll be sure to send more referrals your way!

I use this body shop to only be constantly over impressed with the turn out. They painted my bed due to a fender bender. Good work ain’t cheap and cheap work ain’t good! Remember you will always walk up to your car/truck/suv and see a terrible job. Mike and his staff are amazing!