First Choice Auto Repair & Tire Center in
Woodbury (NJ)

BEWARE!!! This place is a scam! The owner will sell you a dream only for everything to crumble! Do not do business with them! They are liars, and will give you false information! I bought 4 tires that the owner told me was like new, 2 days later the tire went flat. Went back just to find out he sold us a tire that was plugged…Do not buy tires here! He tried to make it seem like I plugged the tire!… read the 1 star comments because they are true! All they want is your money. He wanted to patch the plug and refused to give me another tire! Very rude and told me he is friends with Woodbury police department so nothing will happen if I call the police

i purchased 2 tires from these guys and one of them have plug in it. They tried talking me into puchasing 4 tires while i was there, Thank God i didnt do it. I was not aware of the plug until air started leaving my tire. I called and who ever i spoke to was very rude and acted oblivious to the tire having a plug. I will dispute this service through my bank and submit pictures and receipts with my claim for proof

Terrible experience. The staff here were extremely rude and clearly tried to take advantage of me because I’m a woman. Instead of offering honest advice, they spoke down to me and tried to overcharge for basic services. I got a second opinion and confirmed they were not reasonable with the service I received. It’s disappointing and unacceptable for a business to treat women this way. If you want fair, respectful service, I’d suggest taking your car somewhere else.

THIS TIRE PLACE VERY RUDE AND UNPROFESSIONAL TO THEIR FEMALE CUSTOMERS. They are pushovers when it comes to females. The tires that I have purchased been having multiple slow leaks since buying them. Every time I call, I’m told to ‘check my air pressure more often or that I knew about these tires being faulty when I was never notified .’ These are supposed to be like/ new tires—shouldn’t have to see them slowly deflating so fast if they were purchased just a month or so ago.They clearly don’t stand behind their product. ALSO THIS BUSINESS NEEDS TO BE SHUT DOWN OR THEY WILL BE SUED FOR SELLING THESE FAULTY TIRES AND PUTTING OTHERS IN DANGER

I purchased a tire here a few months ago and asked to inspect it before installation. When I checked the tire, I noticed some small wear and tear along the edge. I asked the technician to find another option, but he returned with what appeared to be the exact same tire and tried to convince me it was different, saying most tires of that size looked similar. After the tire was installed and I drove off, I immediately noticed a wiggling and shaking. I turned around and went back to the shop to have it checked. The technician initially insisted that nothing was wrong, but after the manager inspected the tire, he confirmed the issue was not my fault and replaced it. While I appreciated the manager resolving the problem, my overall experience was frustrating and left me with little confidence in their service. I would not recommend this place.

Joe's experienced team is the best!!! Most importantly you can trust them with your car, which is one of your most precious possessions!! They cared for my disabled neighbor with compassion and have proven skilled at diagnosis. Plus they are genuinely good people and as a pastor that means a lot to me! I've gone to them for oil changes and tires. Most importantly when I was worried that I had a major problem with my Hyundai I went to them with confidence knowing they would be honest even if they could not do the repair but they did ... HOORAY!

This place is very unprofessional & unpleasant. Female customers be aware they will try and get over on you thinking you don’t know anything. Purchase 2 tires that was supposed to be like NEW only to find out 2 days later one of the like new tires already had been plugged. Tried to reach out to them to speak with a manager & they gave me a run around. Do not purchase tires or any other services from this place.

Very unpleasant and unprofessional. If you are a female buyer, beware — they sell used tires while claiming they are new. I purchased a tire a few months ago, only to find out later that it was actually used. The Better Business Bureau will be contacted.

First Choice installed Alloygator rim protectors on all 4 wheels of my Lucid Air. The well known tire service chains I approached did not know how to do this. The work is labor intensive and quite exacting because each tire needs deflating to install the rim protector and then requires reinflating once in place. Joe the owner is a hands on manager who is very concerned with customer satisfaction. It was definitely worth the 45 minute journey to their location to get this work done. Curb rash is expensive to fix as I have found to my cost and I hope these protectors will save me money over time. First Choice did an excellent job at a reasonable price, paying strong attention to detail and to quality, and I was entirely satisfied with their work. Strongly recommend these guys.

I started taking my vehicles to these guys back in 2023. This facility and staff are highly qualified as well as knowledgeable on the latest aftermarket products as well. First Choice does not cut corners and believe the right way is the only way. Thus far, they have done rim protection instalations one 3 of my vehicles, an alignment one 1, and installed my online wheel & tire purchase. With each visit, I have been extremely satisfied with this establishments work. First Choice is my go to shop for tires, suspension, and alignments.

They serve coffee offer quick and speedy service for emergency tire change. Very friendly and good workers. Would recommend.

First Choice will always be our first choice. Joe is very knowledgeable, honest and goes above & beyond! Prices are fair too. If you have a problem with your vehicle, avoid the dealerships and stop in to see Joe and his crew!

Just got a new lift, tires, and rims—and I couldn’t be happier! Joe, the owner, was incredibly knowledgeable and took the time to walk me through all my options. He really helped me decide what would work best for my Jeep and my budget. The whole process was smooth, and the end result looks and drives amazing. Highly recommend!

I just had Joe and his men fix my F450 Dually pickup Truck. I purchased tires for it on the Eastern Shore Virginia and the 6 new tires that I got down there could not rebalanced and made driving my truck miserable. I tried to have them rebalanced 3 time at different tire centers. Joe and Ed took my truck and replaced all 6 tires with new tires and it is hard to believe that this is my F450. It has never driven and rode this good . I would recommend First Choice Tire Center to anyone who needs work done on their car or truck. Joe and Ed and their mechanics are excellent at what they do and they make sure that it is done correctly. I know that I can drive this truck back to my house on the Eastern shore and it will be an enjoyable ride . Thanks Chris Reynik

I've gone to Joe's shop for nearly 10 years and it seems everyone locally whose in the know, understands that he's the guy to go to. Integrity is of all time importance to him as he makes sure to be thorough in how he advises you while also genuinely caring about your costs so you're most efficiently upkeeping your car without overspending. In fact his prices appear to be a big value to the competition, and that's just down to his ethics. It's rare to find someone just trying to do right by the community and this is the real deal. Don't just consider him for routine maintenance by any means as his specialty is lift kits and custom wheels. He's the only person i trust for quality work driven by a trusted consultation.

I got AlloyGator rim protectors installed on my Tesla Model X at First Choice: they're a certified AlloyGator installer. They did a fantastic job and were happy to do the installation. I highly recommend this shop to other Tesla owners for work on rims and tires!

This place is awesome. Great prices and great service. I got tires for my truck and my wife's suv both done in the same day.

Great service. Good people. Walked in, no appointment, got a quality used tire. In and out, 15 minutes. They even put the spare back under the bed of my truck. I highly recommend this place.

First Choice Auto Repair and Tire Center offers the best service and customer courtesy. I ordered Toyo RT Trails, but there was a delay in delivery due to the global outage. Ed called me at 2:30pm (on a Friday) to offer Mickey Thompson Baja Boss tires on my truck by the end of the day. Picked up my Truck three hours later very satisfied. As a former Marine, I'm happy to give my money to a business that's a big supporter of the United States Military!

Great place for used tires. Received quality replacements that match the tread of my front wheels. Price was great. Customer service was a bit lackluster but that’s not my focus. Would definitely patronize again.

This was my first time here and I got two brand new m/t front tires (mounted & balanced) and an alignment done for my lifted truck. Both Ed & Joe were very helpful, knowledgeable, and courteous. The prices are fair and the work completed was top notch with no issues. I will definitely be back again!

My first experience was several years ago, I had them put tires on my car, along with rear suspension work. I was very satisfied with the work they performed. Just weeks ago I was having problems with my car shutting off while driving, I thought the worse. They called me to let me know what the problem was and how much. When I got my car back, It runs better than before. Be fore that, I had a vibration in my front-end, and asked them to diagnose that. That ended up being control arms and bushings. I got the car back today, it rides smoother than it has in years. Their prices are very competitive, and I had my car back when they said it would be done. Thank you all at First Choice Auto. Keep up the great work.

Excellent repairs and service! I have had many repairs done by First Choice on my Grand Marquis including replacing the gas tank and car's computer. They always do a great job and provide excellent service for a good price. I would highly recommend them for repairs, tires and general maintenance.

Excellent customer service. I got a 6” bds kit with wheels and tires. They got it done quickly and I could not be happier. Ed worked with me to find the exact look I was going for and Joe made sure I was happy with the finished product. It turned out great. Thanks guys 👍

Best place around, hands down. They do it all and bring it to the table. 5 star, A+ service. Between the great prices, quick service and the over abundance of knowledge that Joe & Ed offer, you can't go wrong in getting exactly what you're looking for. You won't be sorry when you deal with them.

I had a few things done on my 2007 f150 by this shop,including a 6 in. lift with new wheels and tires....ALL work done was above my expectations,and the work was done right the first time..They clean any area that was repaired,no left over grease or oil on or inside my truck,it`s obvious the mechanics here take pride in their work and I appreciate that..,,VERY pleased with First Choice in Woodbury..

Great experience. So glad we found Ed again. He’s very helpful and knows his stuff. I’ll make sure I bring all of my vehicles here.