Garden City Iron & Metal in
-
Address:5 Kenmill St, Columbus, IN, United States
-
Rating:
-
Phone:
-
Methods of Payment:
- Credit cards
- Debit Cards
-
Services:Junkyard
-
Website:
-
Zip Code:47201
Working Time and Location
What clients say about Garden City Iron & Metal in New Columbus (IN)
-
The best prices and services by far these guys and gals will get you the part for the right competitive price guaranteed
Dec 20, 2025 -
I was able to go visit Garden City’s yard and select the part I wanted and it was available the next day. Very accommodating and appreciate them, making their customers a priority.
Nov 25, 2025 -
Aaron was great to work with! Very attention to detail and helped me get the exact part I needed. He made it easy. Thanks!
Oct 15, 2025 -
William came by and picked my car up, he was very nice he was quick to get the job done, we even shared a couple laughs! He was very helpful and didn’t waste any time. He also gave out clear communication on what he was doing and when he paid me!! It was a 10/10 great experience thank you!
Oct 04, 2025 -
Professional and friendly. No problem picking up and towing my car to the junk yard.
Sep 05, 2025 -
So helpful and friendly! Highly recommend. Front desk guy has really added flavor to this company. Flawless transaction went above and beyond by making sure my part fit my car. Customer service top notch.
Sep 02, 2025 -
They were the o only that had the part to my car I called seven different counties and the prices they have are amazing. They kept me informed of everything while pulling my part i highly highly recommend them if your looking for anything!!!
Sep 02, 2025 -
I needed a junk of a car towed to garden city and the rollback driver William came out was super friendly and professional picked up the car and hauled it off will recommend to anyone who needs quick cash for a broke down car.
Aug 29, 2025 -
William did a fantastic job! Right on time! Got my car loaded up quick and was on his way! Definitely recommend asking for him!
Aug 29, 2025 -
William picked up my Impala for me; incredible service. Gave him a $20 for his help and he was very appreciative. Good man, good work. Will call again! Best scrap yard in columbus, probably even county.
Aug 29, 2025 -
If could give zero stars would told me for 3 days was told my part would be ready next day. Was a 5 min pull just 3 bolts got out there end of day today and told they couldn't get to it because had to pull Lexus parts. My 42$ was unimportant.
Jul 30, 2025 -
They deal with you fairly. I've recommended them to several people and will use them again. The gentleman who picked up my car was friendly and professional.
Jul 23, 2025 -
I have a 25 year old 2000 Nissan Xterra that needed a manifold couldn't find it anywhere in the United States of America till I looked into the Garden City Iron and Metal. Thank you for helping the farm car keep moving on!🐝Have a great day!
Jun 22, 2025 -
I absolutely highly recommend this place. They had exactly what I needed and for a reasonable price! The staff were very helpful and friendly and they had my part pulled off and waiting for me.
May 12, 2025 -
In a heart beat I would return to these folks in a pinch, or in anytime at all. They showed hostpitality, honesty, transparency [were informative] and most of all they kept their word!! The only thing I'd have done different is buy more parts ! Lol thank yall && Godspeed
May 09, 2025 -
Lady that helped me was very nice and helpful. took my info got my part very quickly. Great service and price very happy!!!
Oct 17, 2024 -
Listed a cylinder head, sold it to me, called me back 3 days later to tell me it wasn't worth their time at the price they charged me. Now I'm 3 days behind and have customers mad at me because they don't know anything about cars. Avoid.
Jun 11, 2024 -
I had a 2001 Honda Accord with a 3.0 V6 engine. I called multiple times to be certain that I was going to get the right alternator as my car was not running. I was also in a position to where I could not get out here so I had to have a family member come and get it which I explained to the company that I was on house arrest and I couldn't do everything that needed done in a timely manner. They were very friendly and said oh no worries we will take care of you in the time is right! I just brought back the alternator today and they will not give me my $50 refund, They will not give me my core which was $16 and essentially just said sorry about your luck and sent me on my way so if I were you I would not buy anything from this place because they have a habit of pulling parts that do not go to the right car and then if you're busy in life like most people are then you're just SOL because you're not going to get a refund I even asked for a credit and I don't even come here I just needed the alternator I was also refused a credit so as a Google guide and review person I would suggest stay away from garden City scrap metal.
Feb 26, 2024 -
Drove 2 1/2 hours to get parts and they told me the night before they were open from 9 to 12:45. I get there and gate locked and will not answer the phone. They took my info the night before and knew I was coming , could have at least called to let me know they weren’t honoring their word.
Feb 17, 2024 -
If I could have given a no star I would. First off no one knows what they're talking about. They tell you they're going to have a part pulled out by a certain time and then they just skip over you and don't get the part for you. They give you a whole bunch of excuses and lies and reasons on why they wasn't able to get the part. This is the second time I have dealt with not getting a part that I paid for on time. They said they refunded me but I still have yet to see it on my account. I would not recommend getting any parts from here. It sounded like to me that the technician that pulls the parts for you was just being lazy and didn't feel like getting my part out. I recommend going to r&r in connersville.
Feb 13, 2024 -
If I could give less stars I would this place is horrible. They treated my husband horribly because he called and got a price for a part then they wanted to charge him over double. They told him they don't want business from the kind of people like him. He was polite and just questioned them on honoring their price but they didn't like that. Anyone needing parts should just make the short drive to indy if you don't want to be charged 160 for a bumper. Indy is 70. The people here are just awful and their stereotyping my husband in unacceptable.
Aug 23, 2023 -
Drove 6 hours each way to pick up parts for my dealership. Super nice people with a very large selection. 100% the type of people in this world you want to do business with. Thanks for everything.
Jul 01, 2022 -
Kierra and Bree are both very nice and very helpful ladies. Their prices are very competitive and reasonable. (Most of the time...lol) I've been doing business there for several years now and every time I've needed a part, I can find it there.
Mar 11, 2022 -
Very fair on prices. Always go to them my favorite parts yard. Staff is very friendly.
Aug 19, 2021 -
Brianna at Garden city has always been very helpful when I call about parts and pricing. She is very kind and courteous. I have also been there at the yard when she is helping customers she always has a smile on her face and is very helpful To the customers. I will definitely be doing more business with you.
Jul 21, 2021 -
I love coming out to the yard with my husband to get parts. It reminds me of my dad and I when I was young. They have always had the cars we needed parts for and are friendly and helpful. The ladies in the office are super nice and i would definitely recommend checking this place first for all your car needs! Also Matt I had a great idea for a senior project that would help local needy too. I would love to help out with it! Haha.
Apr 30, 2019
Nearest Junkyards to Garden City Iron & Metal
Want to sell your car?
We will buy your car in any condition:
- Blown Engine
- Burned
- Damaged
- Flooded
- Non Running
- Old
- Salvage
- Scrap
- Totaled
- Used
- Wrecked