What clients say about Recycled Sally's in Baraboo (WI)
One stop shop for the whole family. Something for everyone! Been shopping here since I was a kid and now doing the same for my son. Not only are you supporting small business but individuals who are selling as well. Love this place!
I lost a lot of weight, and Sally's basically made it where I could sell my old clothes and use the money to buy smaller sizes in store. I can't tell you how much time and money I have saved replacing my whole wardrobe using her services. 100% recommend to anyone and everyone who is going on a health journey and needs to replace your wardrobe. So many cute things for all shapes and sizes.
One of my fave spots in Downtown Baraboo! The staff is so sweet and helpful, and they always have a great mix of brands and sizes. I’ve been consigning here for years—they know exactly what will sell and go through everything so carefully. Definitely worth stopping in regularly for the new stuff!
My daughter always got gift cards to here and I did think positive of them until they posted an item on social media. My daughter asked them to hold it, they said they would (said she had 24 hours). She drove 25 minutes to get the item. When she arrived, they decided to sell it. I guess they lost a customer.
Fantastic selection of clothing! Mostly women and children but also a small section of men's. This is a consignment shop, so most items are used but trendy and in great condition. Friendly staff, fun atmosphere, clean and family friendly too.
Great place to get lovely clothes for teens, young men, women and children. For women; Chicos, JJill, Banana Republic, Soft Surroundings, etc. I always get compliments on my clothes.
I love to shop here! Staff is friendly, prices are great, clothes are clean and they have lots of higher quality offerings. The best thing is you can shop the items they post on their Facebook page each day, and they will hold the item for 24 hours. Also, they post size, brand, and price with every listing, which is tastefully put together with other items to make an outfit suggestion. I highly recommend Recycled Sally's!!
This place is truly one of those baraboo town treasures! I never after 3 year of living here knew it was here until a friend mentioned it. Prices are super good for lots of brand names. They clearly take a lot of time inspecting what they take in, so you dont feel like you're playing the goodwill does it have a hole or stain game. They post a lot of their items on social media for you to look at there. Staff was so friendly. Will go here for all future clothing needs. I even found a warhwak sweat shirt, super cool for an alum so far from home! Thank you so much for being in baraboo!
My friend and I went in here tonight and the service was amazing and they were super friendly! Shopping can be uncomfortable for me and they made me feel super welcome as a member of the trans community.
My favorite place to shop in baraboo! I also cosign my items there and use that to purchase new items.
The owner is amazing and love going in to see all the ladies.
If you havent checked out this awesome store, run dont walk! Prices are very afforable too. Love supporting local businesses.
Awesome place to recycle and find quality used and new clothing for women and children! Also wonderful small gift ideas for friends! Friendly, helpful staff too!
When I lived in Wisconsin, this was my favorite place to be on my day off. Thrifting is a major hobby of mine and this place never disappointed. Super friendly, sweet and fashionable staff. Affordable prices and a really cute store layout! I highly recommend checking this shop out. Would love to go back some day :)
Love this place! Great selection of women & children's items! Great prices & who doesn't love recycling & saving money. I will say, they are also very easy to deal with when it comes to selling items. Gotta love walking in & having a business write you a check! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!
Love this store! The staff and owner are wonderful and friendly. I have a great turn around with taking my clothing here to sell (much better then Plato’s Closet).
Wide variety of high end/ name brand clothing at a fraction of the cost & great condition. I highly suggest you go check out this local consignment store.
An affordable and quality resale and consignment store for the family located downtown Baraboo. The staff is always friendly. A great shopping option and one of my favorite retailers.
Clean, well organized, friendly staff.
Wondering if they should go on Facebook buy sell trade and ask them if they're interested in bringing in their items on consignment. That may increase their inventory for children's clothing. Just a thought.
Can always find something here. I was a little surprised the last couple visits at the poor quality of a few of the clothing items, and how much they were asking for them. Generally though they have good prices, and items. The sales are great when everything is half off! Amazing deals! They are super easy to sign up for there consignment, and get paid as well. It's alwsy nice to have your current purchase like half paid or more thanks to the credit balance on your consignment account! (Picture is today's $7 purchase!)
Love this place. I started going when I was pregnant and have continued to drive 45 min+ to go. I live in Madison and while there are a ton of children's resale shops in the area, none also include woman's wear (straight, plus and maternity sizes).
I absolutely LOVE this place! I don’t know what I would do without it! I get clothes for myself & my 3 kids for daily wear & every occasion. I love the selection, the owner, the manager & the employees. Highly recommend!!
Great selection, great prices, and very organized so it's easy to find my size and colors. I always find something cute, and the staff is super helpful.
I visit about every 6 months to drop off clothes that my son has outgrown. They are always friendly and start working on the consignment right away. No need to pick up (unless you want to) because they will donate what doesn't sell! Then I am able to check the amount of credit I have at the store. Credit can be used towards new or used items. I haven't checked out the women's clothing recently.
Betsy and her girls always make everyone feel welcome! They only accept the best of the best for consignment, meaning the clothes I get for my kids are always high quality at a lower cost than in the stores. I always recommend this store to all of my mom friends because it truly is the best!
Pretty decent selection of woman's clothes, shoes, and purses. I liked that the children clothes were upstairs while woman's below. It could be improved by having an actual play area so that women with kids in tow could actually look at clothes. Overall decent selection....tho I was a bit surprised at some of the prices considering a consignment store but I would return bc they had great sales on off season items. In summary, cute little jem of a store.
Website
