Employee dropped the bomb at Bayside Bargins. Was incredibly rude and shoved customers out of store. Screamed at me for holding item close to closing. Ripped item out of my hand while demanding “nope, nope, give it to me now!” And all customers were shocked by the great disrespect shown by the employee! Weve always enjoyed our shopping experience there multiple times, but now will never step foot in there again, worrying that this time insted of ripping item out of my hand, he will rip my arm off instead and still kick me out. Clearly this man has passive aggressive tendencies and should not work in the retail business!!! ? CUSTOMERS BEWARE!!!
Broad selection, mixed prices. This is a fun consignment shop with a little bit of everything, from art to furniture to sets of dishes. Quality and priced vary but turnover is quick and there are definite bargains to be had. Our favorite theift shop in door county.
I love this place. My wife and I frequent often, and we always joke that we have to go in "with a plan," because we will end up walking out with some miraculous treasure we weren't expecting!
The items are diverse, the shipments move quickly, and all of the staff are really awesome and hearty.
We have been shopping here for over a year, and I would like to say we have more and more things starting to fill our house from Bayside!
And if you are trying to sell anything, the set-up is super easy, each seller has a code, and when the item is sold, you get a monthly breakdown of it, you can then either cash it as a check or use it as credit for the next purchase.
Really awesome gem, and definitely worth stopping in to see for yourself if you are in the area!
This is one of my favorites! I stop weekly as I refinish furniture. I always find something. Nice strong guys somehow extract my furniture from the big warehouse that's jammed with treasures and get it out to my car with ease. Thank you
tidy, clean and nice secondhand/vintage shop!! The basement has some excellent bargains on furniture, tools, and other such things. I'll definitely be returning when i need to furnish! $23 for a very high quality rolling pin, a useless egg i will be annoying my friends with, and a beautiful desk organizer!!
Great place to locate some second-hand "finds" at reasonable prices. Things you may never even know you were looking for! I've even found some brand new items. Inventory is ever changing and I love that!
Absolutely wonderful store. Very nice staff. Great selection of vintage/antique and a clean and well organized flea market style basement. Very reasonable pricing.
Great store if you don't mind hunting a bit. Some prices were reasonable others a bit high. If you can't find something unique here, you have your eyes closed!
What can I say I love this consignment store. They need to have a sale on hutches and some other stuff to make room in there. Hence then it wouldn't be so hard to maneuver through the disorganization in the lower level.
Bought a hardwood king bed set (matress not included) for $30 had a small indent from what appears to be the claw side of a hammer. Needless to say I love this store. I've never left empty handed
I dare you to visit this amazing treasure trove and not come away with an armful of things you didn't know you needed!! The lower level warehouse size area is not neat and not organized but there are countless gems hiding in plain sight waiting for you to discover them! Prices are reasonable and the fun of exploring is unlimited.
Forget about those expensive boutique shops where everything is trendy and overpriced. This place is the real resale treasure palace. Just dive in and start exploring. Everything from a classic old car to your grandmother's salt shakers.
Stopped in a couple of times recently. The first time was a great experience. Hands down. The second time the staff/owner with the ex-con haircut was unbelievably nasty and rude - completely out of line. I would have never gone back a second time if he had been there the first time.
SEE COMMENT FROM ANOTHER RECENT CUSTOMER - ""Just witnessed an unbelievably rude interaction with a customer by staff/owner?"
Stopped in to look for outdoor bench but found 2 other deals! Store is organized and full of "Bargains"!! Stop in......you won't be disappointed! Here are my bargains.....Minney Mouse sofa/bed and Smoothie Maker!
If you are a bargain hunter, this is a great place to shop. The sales people were friendly and great to work with. I found a little stand that would look great refinished and they gave me a fair price on it . They have a lot of inventory and some of the isle ways are tight walking through because it. No restrooms available for the public.
The staff is fantastic and very helpful. Can't say enough good things about them. They were able to help me, during a difficult time, and helped me make arrangements etc. If you are looking for good second hand items, you will find them here. If you are looking to sell on consignment, you will find them also incredibly helpful
Easily my favorite thrift store in Sturgeon Bay. They've got tons of cool little trinkets, artwork, dishes and some furniture on the upper floor and the basement is filled with more furniture and hardware. Tons of vintage and unique stuff if you're into it like I am, all at very reasonable prices. Keep in mind though, anything under $10 is only payable in cash.
We stopped here just exploring sturgeon bay for the first time. Really wish we would have brought a truck and trailer! AMAZING furniture for the best prices ever! Cute decor and fun vintage items. We were truly on an enjoyable adventure the whole hour we spent in the store. I ended up picking some beautiful items and they were flexible with price since we got so much. I appreciated that! We can’t wait to come back again!
Bayside Bargains always has unique items of interest that you will never find anywhere else. Mike and his staff are amazing, and keep our Sunday visits enjoyable. If you get a chance, stop in and visit them. I gaurantee you will not be disappointed.
It’s a nice enough store with ample inventory. Sometimes I even find a reasonably price item or two to buy inside the main store area. I’d stop more often when I am in the area if the prices in the warehouse were more affordable. The prices out there are more expensive than they ought to be. But it’s Door County so that explains it. Will be back... but will pass on many items, as usual ?
Frequent customer. Nice store with a wide variety of antiques. Good selection of furniture tools, other odds and ends. It's worth a visit if you're in the area.
While it has many unique finds, the prices are alil ridiculous especially on furniture, books and a few other types of items. I did find a few bargains, but mostly nothing I could afford on my budget. If your looking for something different you'll probably find it there, but it'll most likely cost you a pretty penny.
It's a thrift store, so the selection changes daily. There is all sorts of stuff to find from toys to jewelry to furniture. They do not have many (if any) clothes, so do not bother to come here for that. I bought some pins and a bow for arrows. The staff are super helpful.
Website
