American Auto & Tire Service in
New Smyrna Beach (FL)

Consistently & reliably excellent work. Repeat customer. Zero mansplaining. Trusted for a reason. A+

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I had a great experience at American Auto Tire. I came in needing a tire repair and they took care of it quickly and professionally. The staff was super friendly, honest, and efficient. No pressure, no upselling, just solid service and fast turnaround. It’s refreshing to find a local shop that clearly values customer service. If you need tire repair in Edgewater, Florida, I highly recommend American Auto Tire. I’ll definitely be back.

Absolutely unacceptable experience. I purchased a battery on 6/24 and went in to exchange it, expecting a simple process. Instead, I was met with rude and dismissive service. The employee was more focused on watching a football game than helping customers, and his attitude made it clear that we were an inconvenience. He even admitted they had the battery in stock but still refused to complete the exchange. This is not how a business should treat its customers. I strongly recommend taking your business elsewhere.

These guys have been super reliable, truly a rarity in the world of mechanics, where some dude covered in oil is usually trying to scam me out of my hard earned money. I know I can count on American Auto to get the job done, and in a timely manner. I got a chance to chat with the owner a few times too and he was a hoot. If you want the job done right, go here.

My family and I go to American Auto for all of our vehicle needs. The owner EJ was very kind. It is good to be able to trust our local mechanic shop. I definitely recommend!

This company put a rack and pinion in my car after leaving I noticed the truck wouldn’t turn all the way left and I couldn’t make u turns so I took it back and they said my frame was bent and to “tie a chain to the tire and go in reverse” so I took it to a different shop and the amazing guy at hibiscus auto told me the rack wasn’t centered correctly and there is nothing wrong with my trucks frame. So I took it back to American and they basically told me too bad nothing they can do and to just deal with not being able to make U turns after I paid them well over $1500 Edit: it’s about 2 months later from my last review and now my rack has failed and is leaking power steering fluid all over my driveway because not only dose this company do shotty work they use shotty parts 👎

I needed my car checked after an accident. I wanted to make sure it was safe to drive. I drove to their site and they checked my car immediately. The damage was quite severe but they could do the work and have it ready by the end of the day. I needed to go to the hospital because my husband was a patient there. The owner agreed to drive me tto the hospital. En route we decided I needed a re ntal car. He stayed with me until the rental car transaction was complete and I was actually in the car. In addition, he or his son will help me get the rental dropped off when I pick up my car.The service I received was beyond what one would expect! I am very appreciative and highly recommend American Auto and Tire in New Smyrna Beach Florida.

Honest, fast, friendly my go to for tires and mechanical service needs. They treat you like family from the moment you call or walk in the door. They also have recliners in the waiting area if you have to wait, which is great to pass the time by either taking a nap Or working from your phone or laptop!

E.J and his entire staff went above and beyond to take care of me, they didn’t just fix my truck they resurrected the thing. I had many people not only deny the work they accepted but they even corrected the work that others did incorrectly. Truly can’t thank these boys enough, got me back on the road when I was contemplating selling the vehicle.

I take my truck to another garage for oil change and tire rotation and general maintenance. They didn't inform me off maintenance that needed to be done. Took it to America Auto - they did the required maintenance in a couple of hours. I was very pleased with the service!!

On Thursday 9/18 around 4pm, I had an emergency—I needed to drive to NJ that evening, but my air conditioning had failed. It was only blowing hot air and the condenser was kicking on and off. I called American Auto & Tire Service, and they were able to get my truck into a bay right away. In less than an hour, they fully and properly recharged the system and had me back on the road. No nonsense, no upselling—just straightforward, kind, and professional service. These guys are true pros who care about their customers. Thanks to them, I made it to NJ in 24 hours with ice-cold air the whole way. Highly recommend!

I trust American Auto to do only the necessary work at competitive pricing. As a customer of 6+ years, I plan to continue using them for all of my repair needs.

Incredible experience! The owner goes above and beyond. Even though we drive a Volvo he instantly recognized it was not an American Automobile. Good eyes. Honest. Trustworthy. Dependable. Reliable. Enough said.

The staff is great and friendly. As a woman, they do not dismiss you when you come in alone. I have been here before and will always make this my go to for all my vehicles. The prices are very reasonable and they are true to the time it takes to complete service.

If I could give this place 10 stars I would!! Best experience ever hands down! EJ has been nothing but cooperative and very helpful!! I came to American Auto Tire first thing in the morning because I had a nail in my tire and they fixed it right away! I would highly recommend this place if you anything is wrong with your tires! Loved this place so much I made an appointment to get 4 new tires put on!!

Got 4 new tires and an alignment and it was such a pleasure here. They took care of everything and they were so fast. The waiting area is so comfortable. Best place I have ever dealt with.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I am over 1,000 miles away from home on vacation in New Smyrna and needed a tire unexpectedly. American Auto Tires and Service picked up the phone right away and had quick, clear answers for me. They offered same-day service, which was such a relief! They are incredibly friendly and informative. They walked me through my options, explained the warranty clearly, and made the whole process stress-free. I was able to drive straight there and get 4 new tires installed — no hassle. Thanks to them, I feel completely safe driving my family all the way back to Illinois. Highly recommend!

My work truck tire blew out and I needed 3 new ones right away . They were called that day and were able to hook me up right away. They are fantastic. The place is super clean and the staff super friendly even being out in this heat . I recommend personal and work vehicles be taken here

American Auto provided excellent service from start to finish! They quickly diagnosed and resolved an issue with my husband’s truck, and the whole process was smooth, professional, and efficient. We truly appreciated their honesty and expertise—highly recommend to anyone in need of reliable auto service!

Evan and his staff are amazing. This is truly a local hometown honest repair shop. The first time I went there. I had a hole in my car that someone said I needed a new tire. I brought it to Evan and he fixed it and didn’t even charge me from that day on I continue to bring my vehicle to him THREE vehicle three sets of tires. Brake jobs and now struts on my Lincoln town car. He’s also fix my compressor on my air ride suspension honest affordable great shop. I truly recommend if you have car trouble to use them. You will not be disappointed. Thank you for all you do.

I've got flat tires on the road, 200 miles away from the destination, and decided to tow my car to American Auto & Tire. The guys at the shop were real professionals and went above and beyond to make sure that I could get back on the road the same day. AATS is a really good shop, and not only for emergencies. Definitely 5 stars for service and people.

I suggest you take your vehicle to this shop. Staff is incredible and they run an honorable establishment! Clean, respectful…and AMERICAN MADE… I am quite impressed.

I broke down on the side of the road. My car was smoking real bad. I knew it wasn't the new radiator. I called American Auto they told me to bring it in. Took me in right away and knew what the problem was. Very professional.The guy at the front desk was very fast and took the car in.Told me immediately what was wrong and fixed the problem. Very fast service. I will definitely bring my car back for any repairs or Tire service. They even have good Coffee! Excellent service 5 Stars 😊

Very appreciative for squeezing me in at 445 for 4 new tires to be put on. Spent $1379.86. I had one rim with some face front scratches that are old scratches and can tell. None on other rims at all. Now all 4 rims have scratches all around them. Not happy. Also didn't even shine my rims. Also pulled off with all 4 tires at didn't pressures and back left 5 lbs under. I suggested if not enough time I would schedule for tomorrow. Rushing thru an install, causing damage, and sending me on my way shutting doors is not acceptable. It is obvious you scratched my black rims up and no excuse you didn't see it.

EJ and his team took care of us in a timely manner. The shop was nice and clean with an offering of beverages for customers as well. I came in with no AC and left with cold air! Great service and price.

Best auto mechanic shop that I know of. I was referred by a friend and they have never disappointed! I go to American Auto for all my vehicle and tire needs. Thank you for all your hard work and great prices!

Nice clean facility. Fair prices (payment plan if needed) professional service technicians and receptionist Quick flexible service They even have very comfortable recliners for their costumers and vending machines And an optimal location. I highly recommend