This rating is based on customer reviews, inventory size, pricing, and service quality
In Sharon Center, PA, Metalico Shenango Valley earns mostly positive feedback for fast, professional service, quick unloads, and helpful staff; waits are short, the yard is tidy, and they accept a wide mix of metals (batteries; no ACs/microwaves). Many note fair or top aluminum prices. Downsides recur: quoted or posted rates sometimes differ at payout, occasional 100‑lb plastic deductions, required dumping of can bags, and lunch/website hour gaps or surprise closures. Net sentiment feels solid but inconsistent. Overall score: 76/100—good value if you confirm pricing and hours first.
What clients say about Metalico Shenango Valley in Sharon Center (PA)
Great group of people. Quick service. The crane operator is the best around. The location manager is a great guy. Always get the best service. Recommend over and over.
Buyer beware. They have a new policies. It happened to us and we witnessed it to the guy behind us. They will take off 100 lbs for plastic no matter how much there is. We had 5lbs of plastic that's it. Beware it will happen to you
I will NEVER GO TO METALICO AGAIN!. Do not take your metals their people! They will Rip you off so bad its insane! Go to youngstown, anywhere In Youngstown, and you will get triple the price! I've been going for over a week and finally made the trip to u pull it and got triple for the same load. That's a $400 difference!
Very good people to work with. I took a load of cans there and made some good money. The lady on the phone is real nice. The young men working there are very nice. If it's your first time there they will tell you exactly where everything goes and how to get your money. This is the best scrapyard I've ever been to.
Been going here since they opened. Always nice service. Was upset today though, sign was $200/ ton for sheet n cars and they paid out $160/ton. When I asked they said the price dropped but should have honored the advertised price, so beware and watch your ticket before cashing out.
Great place. In and out fast. Only problem is they need to add their business hours to the Web search info. Poor business. Will gladly give 5 stars once this is remedied.
Website
