Windfall Auto Sales in
St. Marys (PA)

Working with Windfall Auto Sales was a fantastic experience. Right from the start, both Dave and Eric were incredibly helpful and made the whole process of buying a vehicle extremely easy.

This place is amazing! They get you in fast! Reasonable prices! Great work! Highly recommend!

The experience was wonderful. The guys treated me very well. Whenever there was an issue, they fixed it. I can't tell you enough how good this place is.

Excellent service. Highly recommended if you're looking for a new used vehicle. Everyone was super helpful.

Everyone is always so friendly and eager to help. This is the 2nd vehicle my husband and I have bought from Eric now the first one I totaled. But I called Eric 2 days after my crash and within days he had found us another one. And even nicer than the first. He also made sure I had another vehicle to use until ours got here seeing it was coming from Virginia. I'm very pleased with Eric and everyone else at windfall auto. Eric also got our daughter in a new vehicle of her own. Would definitely recommend them to anyone looking for a good used car reasonable prices and excellent people.

These guys were very easy to work with! Transparent, friendly, and straight forward. We’re lucky to have a place like this in our area!

My wife and I were truly impressed with the staff at Windfall Auto Sales. From the minute we started looking for a new vehicle, til we took delivery, they were upfront and transparent with us. I definitely recommend Windfall Auto Sales if you are looking for a pre-owned vehicle.

Best place I have ever bought a car. Service was great. Answered all questions. Kept me updated on every thing. I would recommend Windfall Auto Sales to any body. Thank you Eric Odell and staff.

This car dealership is honestly the best I have ever worked with. I talked with Eric there about what I needed from a vehicle and it was like fate was on my side because he had just gotten something in that fit my description perfectly. I went over to test drive it, and he took the upmost care when him and the guys were looking it over. He made the process an absolute breeze! I am beyond happy with my purchase and I intend on returning here for my future vehicle purchases. Thank you so much for making a stressful ordeal into an amazing experience!

I had an incredible experience at Windfall Auto, Dave and Eric went above and beyond to help me get into the right car. They were honest, patient, and genuinely cared about making sure I felt safe and comfortable with everything from start to finish. No pressure, no games, just real people doing right by their customers. I'm so happy with my little car and would absolutely recommend them to anyone looking for a stress-free, straightforward buying experience. Thank you both so much!

The team was very helpful and so friendly! What would’ve taken an hour at a big dealership took 15 minutes. Highly recommend them for buying or selling a vehicle!

Eric really went above and beyond to get us back on the road! Him and his team made the process as easy as it could be. Will definitely be back in the future. Couldn’t be more happy! Love our Jeep!!

Quickest and most friendly car service I ever experienced. They were very professional from the time I went in and out. I would buy another vehicle from them any day!

My husband and I have bought a total of 3 cars from Windfall Auto since they opened a few years ago. They make the car buying process so simple and easy it's hard not to upgrade every couple of years. I also got my vehicle new brakes and tires since they took that side over and love the idea of being able to spread out that cost over several months! The financing process for that was all done online and it was quick and easy!

Quickest and easiest car purchase I have ever made. Eric & Dave are friendly and helpful. Very glad others suggested I go here, I see why. We are lucky to have a place like Windfall Auto Sales in our small area, support them- you will be glad you did.

Loved working with Eric he was extremely helpful and made the whole process extremely painless!!! Great service and very knowledgeable workers! Because of Windfall Auto I'm driving my new car home today!

Absolutely loved my experience with Windfall Auto Sales! The team is incredibly knowledgeable and made the whole process smooth and stress-free. They’re great to work with—honest, helpful, and never pushy. The atmosphere feels like family, and you can tell they genuinely care about their customers. Highly recommend if you’re looking for a smaller, locally owned dealership you can trust!

5-Star experience at Windfall Auto Sales. Dave and Eric took all of the headaches out of the selling process and made it into a smooth and easy transaction. Great communication back and forth. Honest, fair, and fast!

Love the guys at Windfall. Super professional, great vehicles and they treat you like family. We will be doing business here for a very very long time. It's hard to find such an amazing dealership like this in Elk County.

It was a pleasure dealing with Eric and Dave. It was a stress-free car buying experience, and I would recommend them to anyone. No gimmicks or fancy fast talking which I really appreciated. If you are in the market for a used car, go and see them.

I have bought several cars over my lifetime, this was by far the easiest and stress-free place that I have ever been to. The car buying experience here was excellent. Eric and Dave were very easy to get along with, they made my car buying experience easy and stress-free, the next time I go to buy a car I will be sure to look them up. Thank you guys so much you are amazing!

Eric made buying our car nice and easy. He listened to our concerns and had everything looked over and fixed! Best car buying experience yet! Thank you windfall auto!

Best car buying experience I have had. I let Eric know what I was looking for and within a couple days he let me know what he found. They were super easy to deal with, and explain every detail throughout the process. I am extremely happy with my overall buying experience and will 100% be purchasing vehicles from them in the future!

Dave and Eric were fantastic, from the minute we looked at our Traverse to completing the paper work, they were professional and treated us with respect. I definitely recommend Windfall Auto Sales for your next vehicle.

Can’t speak highly enough of my experience with Windfall Auto Sales. I told Dave & Eric what type of vehicle/price range I was looking for and they went to work searching for the right one for me. Very communicative throughout, provided me with several options and their advice on each vehicle. Once we found the right one, the rest of the process was seamless. Don’t limit yourself to what you find on a lot somewhere. Go to these guys and let them find the vehicle that’s right for you.

Highly recommend them! If you are in need of a rental car they will take care of you. Unfortunately, my car sustained damage from a deer and we needed something right away as I am scheduled to be induced tomorrow with the newest addition to our family. The next day after dropping my car off at the garage, we went to Windfall Auto and they got us in a rental car no issue! We are extremely grateful and will be returning for any business we may need in the near future!

Eric was very professional and the customer service was exceptional. We were impressed with the time he took with us making sure we were satisfied with everything. I will definitely purchase cars from Windfall Auto Sales in the future.