Kinley Auto Parts in
Sheridan (WY)

I am leaving this after 9 months to allow people to make an informed decision. My experience with this business has been great, and they proved to be a trustworthy supplier. I found them on Facebook after someone sold a 2008 Chrysler Sebring to my daughter in bad faith. I ordered a motor from them in June 2025, and to date it's running great. It looked nothing like junkyard stuff; I'll add the images below. I have a 2000 Jaguar XKR, which needed a transmission, so I ended up ordering that too from these guys in September 2025, and it also turned out to be good. They are responsive, and communication was excellent. Overall I'm satisfied with both purchases. Highly recommended!!

AVOID AT ALL COSTS! I worked with Kinley for weeks finding a nice engine for a project car and agreed upon an engine and VIN# with 66k miles on it. Kinley ended up shipping me a completely different engine from another VIN # with 114k on it. AND to top it off the car has been sitting for 4 years. The engine has rusty valves, corrosion on the coolant passages, and failed a compression test (see pictures). I contacted Kinley to resolve this and they wasted my time for 2 months saying they are working it out with the supplier. They are no longer responding to my emails and they hang up on me when I call them. I am still actively working on getting a refund out of them almost 5 months later.