This rating is based on customer reviews, inventory size, pricing, and service quality
For Junk Car Direct in South Milwaukee, WI, sentiment skews negative: several 1-star reviews report unsafe or short-lived parts, no refunds, and an unreachable phone—indicating customer service and quality-control concerns. One 5-star counters with fair pricing and a positive deal, noting parts sales and towing. Pricing appears competitive, but reliability and accountability are recurring issues. Limited insight on inventory variety, yard organization, part-finding ease, or wait times. Overall: 40/100 with a negative trend.
Address:
1200 Minnesota Ave, South Milwaukee, WI, United States
What clients say about Junk Car Direct in South Milwaukee (WI)
WARNING: Dishonest & Shady Business
I bought a tire from this junkyard after being told it was “like brand new” with no issues. The second I brought it to my trusted tire shop (who I’ve gone to for years), they showed me a hidden tear in the inside sidewall — making the tire unsafe and worthless.
When I messaged the seller, instead of taking responsibility, they gave me excuses and even tried to blame my tire shop for damaging it — which is ridiculous since I literally watched the installation. They refused to give me any refund or help at all.
Selling unsafe junk while advertising it as “good as new” is a scam. This isn’t just shady, it’s dangerous. A tire with a sidewall tear can blow out and cause a serious accident. The fact that they removed the listing off Marketplace right after says it all.
Bottom line: they take your money, sell you unsafe junk, and then shrug it off. Absolutely no integrity, no customer care, and no accountability. Stay FAR away — don’t risk your money or your safety here.
I was told that the parts I was buying were pretty fair condition the next day after repairing my car the struts where in poor condition didnt even get a week out of them smh I tried calling numerous of times no awnser I feel like I got scammed
Website
