This rating is based on customer reviews, inventory size, pricing, and service quality
Based on recent feedback, Cleveland Auto Sales & Salvage in Cleveland, WI scores 85/100. Sentiment is largely positive: customers praise friendly, professional staff (often Jake), fair-to-great pricing, honest part descriptions, quick ordering/shipping, and fast turnaround that makes parts easy to get. Inventory is usually on hand—from body panels to tires—and refunds were prompt when a match wasn’t right. Common complaints: occasional yard/organization lapses (a paid part couldn’t be found), selective vehicle purchasing, sometimes high prices, and an isolated but serious customer service incident. Overall solid, with a few rough edges.
Badly organized…. Found a trunk lid online, called and paid for it they said it would be ready in a hour. Then they called me back three hours later and said they couldn’t find the car anywhere on the lot, kinda weird because usually you’d make sure you had the car before charging customers… they did refund me right away but it’s just a bad experience.
All I did was call today and inquire about a part. Jake was the one on the phone and he was extremely helpful and nice about it. I will continue to do business here
Jake from Cleveland auto parts was extremely helpful! He found the part I needed and got it shipped to me so quickly I had the part the next day! Great service I would definitely recommended them! Thanks Jake and Cleveland auto parts for all your help!
If I could give this place zero stars I would. Someone prepurchased a product for me and instructed the business to leave it outside. I get there 4:57 after driving an hour after work to make it their in time. The door was already locked and the sign showed closed even though they have it posted it is 5:00 they close. They let me in, okay amazing, but then they gave no indication or have no posting the door would slam into me as I am walking in. The door hit my ankle and tore a ton of skin off the back. I immediately started bleeding and filled up a huge band-aid. I have a super high pain tolerance and I physically could not speak for 30 seconds. The guy who watched this happen said "yeah you're like the third person that has happened to now." They really need to put up a sign. It is now a week later and my ankle is STILL swollen and bruised after 8 full days. At this point of it being a week I am frustrated and called for a refund for having such poor service and experience at the business. They were hesitant when I asked to speak to a manager, the manager would not let me speak to the owner. I was told "you just want something for free." I explained I waited a whole week before even saying something and that if I really wanted to I could proceed with a lawsuit, he told me to go head to do that because all I am trying to do is get something for free. I HAD TO NURSE A WOUND INFLICTED AT THEIR BUSINESS FOR A WHOLE WEEK. I said that I have worked in customer service for a long time and that when companies have someone who has an injury OR a very poor experience they do something to make things right. That is INTEGRITY. I'm not asking for hand outs. I am angry at the business and the manager who assumes I want free things and doesn't understand if they don't have a sign up, just like if a business does not have a "wet sign" up and someone slips and falls they can be sued. It is all about making it right for the customer. Especially after they drove almost an hour ONE way to give you business. Extremely rude and condescending on the phone. He said "this goes against everything I believe in, I will give you half refund and then this is over and done with and it wont be talked about again." Just a note, I grew up in Sheboygan county and I understand this is how some of the county operates but I'm no longer from around there and live in one of the top 10 wealthiest counties in Wisconsin. I'm not looking for handouts so don't assume, I'm looking for the business to make things right and when I spend money I could have put towards college after a poor experience, I am going to want that back.
Color of the doors I bought was not matching the color of my car for some reason. They gave me my money back right away. I will recommend this place to all my friends.
