Andy's Main Street Auto in
-
Address:604 S Main St, Holmen, WI, United States
-
Rating:
-
Phone:
-
Methods of Payment:
- Credit cards
- Debit Cards
-
Services:Auto repair shop
-
Website:
-
Zip Code:54636
Working Time and Location
What clients say about Andy's Main Street Auto in Holmen (WI)
-
Great price and was almost half of what another place in town was charging for the same job.
May 09, 2026 -
I brought my car into Andy’s Main Street Auto expecting a simple, one-hour job to replace my power steering and serpentine belts. What I got instead was a week-long, expensive mess that honestly should never have happened. The first time I picked up my car from the guy, I was told everything was good to go. Within minutes of driving, I noticed a loud ticking noise coming from the belts. When I brought it back, instead of taking responsibility, Andy told me I needed another part and to come back Monday. In the meantime, the belts literally came off when I started my car, forcing me to pay for a tow back to the shop. The worst part is, when my dad calls to figure out what was going on, Andy admitted he noticed an issue the first time he worked on my car but chose not to say anything because, in his words, “he’s just a kid and only asked for the belts.” That is completely unacceptable. As a young adult I may be ignorant to everything that needs to be replaced but I still feel like it’s basic decency to tell someone that a part needs to be changed or else the part will make you stranded on the side of the road. After going back Monday and supposedly getting everything fixed, the issue came right back. Within ONE day and only a few starts of the car, the ticking returned and the belt already had visible damage again. I had to take it to another shop just to avoid being stranded. What should have been a quick, straightforward repair turned into multiple trips, extra costs, a tow bill, and a lot of unnecessary stress. The lack of communication, poor workmanship, and dismissive attitude was as shocking as a new customer. If you value your time, money, and safety, go somewhere else. After taking it to a different place already I am always being told that they don’t know how anyone can leave the belts on in good faith the way they were, they also told me where the problem was and Andy never mentioned this as well, so I’m assuming to him it’s my fault that I didn’t ask about it. I would not trust this place with even the simplest repair.
Apr 07, 2026 -
Saved me thousands fixing what was actually wrong not what the last mechanic said was wrong.
Mar 09, 2026 -
Our 2016 Town & Country van started making a chirping sound, and we needed to have it fixed before an upcoming road trip. I called multiple places in the area to get quotes and timeframes, and I’m so glad I contacted Andy’s Main Street Auto. They asked me to bring the van in the same day I called. They quickly determined that the serpentine belt and pulleys needed to be replaced, and the mechanic had everything fixed in less than an hour. By taking it to Andy’s Main Street Auto, we saved over $300 compared to other quotes. I would highly recommend giving Andy’s Main Street Auto the opportunity to earn your business. Honest, fast, and affordable service.
Jan 10, 2026 -
Tried a different shop. Took it to andys. They illegally changed a part on the vehicle. Never was notified about the change, until it was time to get the vehicle. Now with this info I will never go back. Also getting people involved to have the wrong done right. I do not recommend.
Oct 30, 2025 -
We had an issue with our truck on a cross country move and Kugar and Joey got us in right away with a repair and advice. Really friendly people and great service. Kugar even gave us a bag of cucumbers from his farm!
Sep 02, 2025 -
Andy and his crew are fantastic. Cordell's Automotive quoted me over $1,800 for repairs I suspected were unnecessary. Andy got the job done for just $340 problem solved, no upsell, no nonsense. Enough said!
Jun 26, 2025 -
Took my car here a few months ago, they did great work and were very fair on their pricing. Will continue to take my vehicle here.
May 27, 2025 -
My van's alternator went out and Andy not only told us to bring it in that day, but him and his crew also fixed it that same day! The other mechanic we called wouldn't even have been able to look at it for 8 days. Every time we have used Andy's we have been happy with the service, and this time was no exception. Would highly recommend Andy's to anyone needing a fair and honest mechanic with great service and pricing.
Dec 31, 2024 -
Haley and Claire are my servers they did a very good job of getting me my pancake right away and keeping my coffee cup filled and bringing me a glass of water it all made a beautiful morning
Dec 04, 2022 -
Andy is awesome! Would recommend this place to anyone looking to support small local and have a A++ experience!
Oct 31, 2022 -
Let me start by saying andy is a great mechanic and has done great work IN THE PAST. My last experience with this business was awful. never tell a customer you could care less about their repair. you have lost all business from myself and anyone i know who has taken their vehicle there in the past.
May 26, 2020 -
I have never had a bad experience here. Andy has always been top notch and honest with what needs to be done.
Aug 03, 2019 -
If you are looking for a dependable and trustworthy auto repair shop, look no further. Andy has been a great resource for my vehicle maintenance and repairs without breaking the bank. Thank you Andy!
Mar 16, 2017
Nearest Junkyards to Andy's Main Street Auto
Want to sell your car?
We will buy your car in any condition:
- Blown Engine
- Burned
- Damaged
- Flooded
- Non Running
- Old
- Salvage
- Scrap
- Totaled
- Used
- Wrecked