Elite Foreign & Domestic Auto in
Port Jefferson (NY)

We've used Elite Auto since moving to the area from Colorado with an old RAV4 whose A/C was long broken (not so bad in Colorado, unbearable in the Long Island summer!). Elite fixed that, and we've have had uniformly positive experiences ever since on both routine inspections / maintenance and a couple of bigger jobs where they've gone out of their way to find reasonably priced options for repairs.

We have been using Elite exclusively for over 10 years. Appreciate they allow for appointments and always finish the work in the time they state. They also give you a heads up on work to be expected in the next 3-6 months based on driving. And small details like the fact I scheduled an oil change not knowing I needed an inspection. They took care of it while there. Highly recommend.

Excellent service! Professional and courteous staff! Highly recommend!

These guys take the stress out of car maintenance. Making an appointment is easy, I get updates during the process, and Rich and Tony answer all the questions I have with expertise and good humor.

We've taken our three cars to them for years. Always reliable, fair, and easy to work with. Highly recommended.

we've been going to Elite for 20 years and we've always been pleased with their service. They are extremely professional, competent and unfailingly polite. We would never take our cars anywhere else.

First time at Elite. This is not an “address the complaint, throw parts at it and move on” place. Richie paid attention to everything I told him, thoroughly went through my aging bmw, found the issue- even uncovered a little surprise- communicated with me clearly throughout. I was uneasy about it at first bc I have a trusted specialist, but they are far away from me and cost and timing for dropoff and pickup were too cumbersome. I’m glad I went with Elite, my car is happy and so am I. Would recommend.

The absolute best. They’ve taken care of our vehicles for over 15 years, which is why they’ve run exceptionally for that time. Honest, reasonably priced, empathetic and so much more…. If you don’t have a mechanic and need one, like a trusted family member, don’t look any further. Begin your relationship now and check that box/worry off your list of 8,000 adult things to do. Lighten your mental load, and allow these fantastic professionals to do what they do so excellently. Gratefully, and hoping it helps you all. Preston

We’ve been bringing our cars to Tony, Richie, and the team at Elite Auto for several years. They’re very knowledgeable about a wide variety of vehicles, very honest and straightforward, reliable, and always go out of their way to help. Great expertise and service, wouldn't go anywhere else!

All I can say is “WOW” . I have never been to a business so well run with Knowledgeable mechanics and an owner who knows his stuff! From family haulers to sports cars these guys know it all!

Just found my new mechanic. These guys are great and thorough. Pricing is slightly higher than average but their work is well above average. I had an extensive repair and the turn around was quick and clean.

Elite has been taking care of my family's cars for 35 years, and my own cars for over 20. They provide some of the best service I've gotten in any industry. The guys provide excellent diagnostics, accurate pricing estimates, and deliver work on-time and when promised. When they aren't sure about something, they say so there's no surprises. Richie always provides excellent communication on that status of repairs. The breadth of their knowledge of different cars is really astounding. Not only have they maintained our standard Jeeps, Hondas, Nissans, and GMCs, but they also regularly take care of Mercedes, Porches, and other imports/exotics. Of particular import of us is their ability to do complex and custom work on my son's modified 1966 Mustang. It's had a lot of alterations made by former owners including a motor swap from an inline 6 to a 1990's V8. Some of the old DIY work was done poorly, and Elite is helping us get it all sorted out and make sure repairs are done the right way. Their extensive knowledge of a mishmash of 60's and 90's tech installed in the car has been key. Tony does a great job of explaining why things work they way they do on this car, and why he's fixed things certain ways the balance safety, performance, and cost. Little on the car is standard and their ability to ID issues, source the right parts, and in some cases custom fabricate pieces to solve issues has been astounding. All for a very reasonable cost. Whether you have a plain jane daily driver, an expensive luxury import, or a vintage car Elite can take care of it for you.

Absolutely the best shop around. They’ve always taken great care of my car every time I have brought it in (which has been often). They’re quick, they’re flexible and they do a great job. My family has been going there for years. I trust them 100%.

I can not adequately convey how fortunate I feel at having discovered Elite Auto. I had driven by the location countless times over the decades, without realising that the finest automotive repair shop in the region was so close by, hiding behind that neat white picket fence. I have done all sorts of work on my own cars of various vintages for decades. Along the way, I have had incidental contact with many automotive repair shops. Most of these experiences reinforced my resolve to do the work myself. It is a sad fact that the distribution of ability means that most people are not very good at what they do. Automotive repair has always been highly technical, and the complexity of modern automobiles makes such high intellectual demands that few mechanics are truly qualified. Circumstances forced me to seek a shop to do mechanical work on an unusual modern car (Smart ForTwo) that many shops either refuse to touch, or fail to service successfully. Consultation with various local and regional shops was deeply disappointing. It was through an internet search that I found Elite Auto and the unusually stellar reviews they have received. A visit disclosed a very neat shop and grounds, and exceptionally friendly, helpful, and technically astute people. I had been reluctant to place my beloved car in the hands of others, but such was the high impression conveyed by the visit, and some technical discussion, that my reservations quickly evaporated. The outcome could not have been better. Elite Auto managed to solve a very difficult problem that had rendered the car unusable, and the work was done in exact accordance with my unusual requirements. Communication was superb, and the uniformly friendly manner bespeaks a happy workplace. Elite Auto will perform repairs to a very high standard, and their exceptional ability with diagnosis will save money by avoiding needless trial-and-error replacement of costly parts. It would be impossible for me to recommend them too highly.

Great shop. Highly recommended. I was referred to this shop after my regular mechanic would not perform the exhaust manifold repair on my truck. Friendly, professional, looked over my truck and provided an estimate of work needed before starting. Repairs were performed with no issues. Noted my rear brakes were also very low which was somehow missed when the oil was changed <2K miles prior. I would recommend bringing your vehicle(s) to them. I will be returning after the experience.

The work they do at Elite is top notch. Tony and his crew have done brakes, clutches, and electrical repairs among other work that has been needed and I have never had to go back to get something "refixed." Elite knows cars better than the dealers and will not try to sell something that is not needed. Elite is the only place I let touch my cars. I wish there were more stars to click on.

Always a pleasure with the Gents at Elite Auto, Tony and Rich are knowledgeable and courteous. I make the drive from 30 mins away, worth the drive. Whether it’s a trailer hitch, brake job or just an inspection, I won’t go anywhere else!

Absolutely fantastic service! My mechanic went above and beyond to ensure my car was in perfect condition. From the moment I arrived, I was impressed by their professionalism and attention to detail. They explained everything clearly and provided fair pricing. The quality of their work is top-notch, and my car runs better than ever. I highly recommend this mechanic to anyone in need of reliable and expert auto repair. Five stars all the way!

10/10 experience. When we got home my husband said, “I’ve never had a mechanic experience like that. How did you hear about that place?” From start to finish and pick up, the experience was above and beyond our expectations. Throughout the time they had our car, the communication and explanation, and analogies to understand, were so helpful. We could not be happier. This place is the gold standard. Highly recommend.

I was having a big problem with my Audi it’s 2011 q5 s line. We had a parasitic drain and nothing much worse than this. We had it at another shop and they became frustrated and just couldn’t get it fixed. I came over to elite and they were able to get it fixed first shot. I cannot tell you how happy I am to know they made sure it was fixed before they gave it back. All my vehicles will come to their shop for now on.

If there is something wrong with your car, they'll find it. This is an excellent garage and my family has trusted them for years to keep our vehicles in good condition. They are thorough, professional and easy to deal with. Strong recommendation.

Elite has been an excellent auto team for us. They are professional and courteous. Richie is always happy to walk me through the work and answer any questions I might have. I highly recommend them.

Excellent customer service, and attention to detail. I scheduled an appointment to get my brakes fixed Friday morning, I drop my car off at the wrong mechanic and missed the appointment time (just my luck 🥲) However Richie still squeezed me in to service my car. I’m happy 😃

My number one choice for any of my mechanical needs whether it be my foreign auto or my domestic auto. Never disappointed never any unexpected surprises or charges. Phenomenal customer service, the fact that the owner tony is hands on and interacts with the customers is a major plus. Highly recommend this shop to everyone/anyone who needs any type of work done on there automotives

Can't say enough good things about Tony, Richie and the rest of the staff. Been going to them for quite a while now and have always received great service and advice from them. Very professional well run organization. Recently had a new Jeep prepped to be towed behind my motorhome (tow brace, wiring, etc)I explained my concerns and they addressed them completely and did a beautiful job. Even on the road thousands of miles away, with my previous tow (NOT set up by them unfortunately) when I had an issue, I could call them for their advice. Always very generous with their time and advice. Knowledgable and skilled, their prices are very fair.

I have used Elite Auto for years - the work is uniformly excellent and reasonably priced. They are always honest and 100% reliable. Just recently I had an issue when I discovered a flat tire as I was leaving for a week long vacation. Intending to schedule an appointment for my return, I called them - but they told me it wasn't a great idea to let the car sit on a flat tire for a week. So while I was away, they came to my house, picked up the car, fixed the tire, and brought it back - and there is was, waiting for me upon my return. I can't imagine such good service anywhere else. Thank you, Tony, Richie, Kevin, Donna and everyone at Elite Auto!

I went to Elite based on the many positive reviews here and I'm so glad I took the recommendations! Tony and Richie have the most wonderful customer service skills. They clearly explained to me what my car needed, provided prompt and professional service, & they even waited late for me on a Friday night to make sure I had my car for the weekend. These guys are passionate about cars and it shows. My car is running great now and I'm so happy to have found this reliable place!