Mt. Sinai Tire Inc. in
-
Address:797 NY-25A, Miller Place, NY, United States
-
Rating:
-
Phone:
-
Methods of Payment:
- Credit cards
- Debit Cards
-
Services:Auto repair shop
-
Website:
-
Zip Code:11764
Working Time and Location
What clients say about Mt. Sinai Tire Inc. in Miller Place (NY)
-
Very Poor customer service at this location, turns away customers half hour before closing when not busy which is unacceptable, front desk secretary needs to learn manners and proper business etiquette.
Nov 19, 2025 -
The business closes at 5pm. I arrived just before 4:30 kindly asking for assistance with a nail in my tire. This is not a long job. The guy at the front desk pointed at the clock (4:30) and told me no. I then called the store after and the technician said yes he could. He then checked with the guy up front and refused to assist. I guess they close at 4:30 if you’re wondering.
Nov 18, 2025 -
I had two tires fixed here and received excellent service. The gentleman who helped me was patient, knowledgeable, and very kind. He took the time to listen, addressed the issues with my tires, and even checked the other two for me. Truly great customer service—thank you so much!
Sep 26, 2025 -
Locally owned community tire shop that deserves our business. They are professional, knowledgeable, and thorough. I’ve taken my vehicles to the cheap tire corporate shops (STS Tire & Mavis Tire owned by the same people, Walmart, Pep-boys, Firestone, and Sears) and always seem to have issues. Last time I went to Mavis for one of my vehicles I specifically requested them to clean the bead before mounting the new tires. They said they know how to install tires. Guess what the tire had air leaks around the entire bead of all four tires because they did not clean the beads. This has happened a number of times before and that is why I asked for them to do the cleaning. Vowing not to to return to the big corporate store, I brought my car to Mt Sinai Tire and they found the leaks, removed all four tires completely, sanded, cleaned, and painted them all. They prepped the rim and painted it as needed and remounted and balanced the tires. I will not go elsewhere for tires. They have earned my trust. They were worth every dollar! Honest, hard working, and locally owned small business. Thank you guys!!!!!
Mar 16, 2025 -
Well attendant too... reasonable,and courteous...been here 3 times never disappointed.👍
Jan 19, 2025 -
Honest and real friendly fixed my tire when goodyear said it was un repairable. These men will tell you the truth and do the work
Jan 15, 2025 -
My first impression was superb customer service and koodos to the gentleman that took the nail out of my tire was excellent. There was no wait time I was seen right away. He carefully took the screw that was hanging out of my tire out super quickly. I have recommended this tire shop to my family and friends.
Sep 19, 2024 -
Mount Sinai Tire is a family owned business, and I have known them for years. Gary and his team are upstanding, and offer unparalleled knowledge, skill, integrity, and honesty. It is where I have, and will always go for my auto repair needs. God bless!
Sep 03, 2024 -
Mr. P and his guys are the best. They have done an alignment for me, and also mounted/balanced numerous tires and wheels. Always VERY fairly priced and have a great turn around time. Also always willing to go the extra mile when I needed stuff back quickly. Great business to deal with.
Sep 21, 2023 -
Dan replaced my tire and was quick AND was a bill less than what Firestone Medford charged me 2 months earlier (they also put the wrong tire -.-) If you want competence, more than fair price, and kindness (very few folks have all three especially in this day and age) try these guys out. I have to thank Mike G Perfection Auto Body for recommending them. Thanks Mike, you were right. 👍
Apr 10, 2022 -
Dan did a great job restoring my tire. I dropped in and left 15min later with a fixed tire.
Jul 01, 2021 -
Gary and his staff are extremely professional and honest. Im so grateful this shop is next door to me office. I use them for everything now and its so convenient. I even locked my keys in my truck and they sent someone over and got my truck open in record time! So thankful for these great guys! Definitely recommend!
Jan 19, 2021 -
Gary and his crew are honest, fair and the best mechanics around. Only place I or my family would go. Great shop.
Oct 15, 2020 -
Gary was absolutely awesome! I went to 2 other shops to get a estimate, and Gary beat them both by $500. He also fine tuned my truck with no additional charge. Gary is the only Mechanic I’ll ever go to, and you should also go to Mt. Siani Tire for the best price, and exceptional service!
Sep 26, 2020 -
Professional service with experience solving unknown tire problems. Going there for over 15 years.
Jul 15, 2020 -
Mt. Sinai Tire was absolutely amazing! Getting ready to go on a road trip with my motorhome and they went above and beyond! I only needes one valve stem to be replaced but they went ahead and checked all my tires to make sure they were safe and even went as far as checking a fuse for me for something unrelated! Highly recommend them and they will continue to get my service from now on!
May 22, 2020 -
I have been dealing with Gary for almost 20 years. If he said the screw needed to be replaced rest assured it did. And he did change it. Honest mechanic with a high degree of integrity.
Apr 28, 2020 -
Changed my tires in 4 hours without a wheel lock. Great service and will be coming back in the future!
Dec 10, 2019 -
The people are friendly, helpful and knowledgeable. I recommend them all the time.
Nov 24, 2019 -
These mechanics are the only ones in can trust. They always do good by us and always know the answer.
Aug 17, 2019
Nearest Junkyards to Mt. Sinai Tire Inc.
Want to sell your car?
We will buy your car in any condition:
- Blown Engine
- Burned
- Damaged
- Flooded
- Non Running
- Old
- Salvage
- Scrap
- Totaled
- Used
- Wrecked
We serve the below locations in this area
- Amagansett
- Amityville
- Babylon Township
- Baiting Hollow
- Bay Shore
- Bayport
- Bellport
- Blue Point
- Bohemia
- Brentwood
- Bridgehampton
- Brightwaters
- Brookhaven Township
- Center Moriches
- Centereach
- Central Islip
- Cold Spring Harbor
- Commack
- Copiague
- Coram
- Cutchogue
- Deer Park
- East Hampton Township
- East Islip
- East Moriches
- East Northport
- East Patchogue
- East Quogue
- Eastport
- Eatons Neck
- Farmingville
- Greenlawn
- Hampton Bays
- Hauppauge
- Holbrook
- Holtsville
- Huntington Township
- Huntington Station
- Islandia
- Islip Terrace
- Kings Park
- Lake Grove
- Lake Ronkonkoma
- Lindenhurst
- Manorville
- Mastic
- Mastic Beach
- Mattituck
- Medford
- Melville
- Middle Island
- Montauk
- Nesconset
- North Babylon
- North Bay Shore
- Northville
- Oakdale
- Orient
- Port Jefferson
- Port Jefferson Station
- Riverhead Township
- Rocky Point
- Sag Harbor
- Sayville
- Selden
- Shelter Island Township
- Shirley
- Smithtown Township
- Southampton Township
- Southold Township
- St. James
- Stony Brook
- Wading River
- Wainscott
- West Babylon
- West Islip
- West Sayville
- Westhampton
- Westhampton Beach
- Wyandanch
- Yaphank
- Remsenburg-Speonk
- Vernon Valley
- Bayberry Dunes