This rating is based on customer reviews, inventory size, pricing, and service quality
Guffey's Automotive LLC in Maple City, MI scores 99/100. Reviews are overwhelmingly positive: customers praise honesty and professionalism, fair pricing, and expertise with both gas and diesel. Many report quick diagnostics, same-day help, and clear communication—strong signs of fast, customer‑first service. Staff are friendly and trustworthy, with work that earns repeat business. Complaints are rare; however, there’s little detail on parts inventory, yard organization, or ease of finding parts, so those aspects remain unclear.
What clients say about Guffey's Automotive LLC in Maple City (MI)
Experience and Trust. I only spent a few minutes with these folks. (car issue on vacation....blah) but through clear experience and integrity Guffrey's was able to address the issue. I am grateful. Thank You. These guys are who you want handling your automotive issues.
Amazing place for your car needs! Was driving around and my tires light came on. Stopped by and he quickly came out and checked my tires and determined it's just a tpms sensor! No big deal! On the road again :)
These guys were the best! I had an oil change in Chicago at a dealership, made it up north and my car was smoking. They were busy but fit me in same-day and went above and beyond. So nice and helpful—highly recommend!!
Awesome place to bring your car or truck. Diesel or gas, these guys do a damn good job. Fit me into their loaded schedule, very honest, fair pricing, and professional staff. Will definitely be back to have my truck wrenched on. Thank you Garret.
Don’t tell anyone, but I believe I’ve stumbled on an honest mechanic. I had an oil leak. Of that I was certain. I’m ok with troubleshooting vehicles. I change my own oil, plugs, etc., but when I saw a huge puddle of oil under my truck, I didn’t want to take any chances. I’ve had a couple of really, bad experiences with mechanics in this region so I wanted to try someone new.
I called Garrett. He is obviously quite busy and didn’t need to help me. He went out of his way to allow me to bring it by just so he could get a look and see if the root cause was obvious. I added oil and hit the road. Next thing I know, Garrett is under my truck and has identified the issue. It was (embarrassingly) a loose, oil filter. I have no idea how or why that was the case as it’s been quite a while since my last oil change and it’s only recently begun leaking, but the point is Garrett probably could’ve told me anything.
Not only did he not mislead me, but he fixed it right there on the fly, topped me off, and tried several times to refuse payment. The world could use a few million more people like Garrett. I met his father while at his shop and see where Garrett gets his integrity from. I just want to publicly recognize him. I’ve had a few, bad breaks recently and really didn’t need a new, truck payment. Thank you, Garrett. I sincerely appreciate your kindness today. I guarantee I’ll be back in the future and next time I’ll wait my turn.
My diesel truck developed an oil leak while we were in the area on vacation. Garrett squeezed in a check on my truck, made a quick fix, and had me back out the door quickly. Finding a diesel mechanic anywhere can be a challenge. Thank you so much for taking care of my F350!
My husband and I were on a road trip and noticed we had a flat tire. Guffey’s was the closest auto repair to us. Garrett and Connor were so quick to help us with our tire. They are so incredibly friendly, helpful and kind. They are thorough and helped us get back in the road quickly.
After recently moving to Traverse City, I had a few problems with the battery in my car. Garrett hooked my car battery up to a computer, found the issue, and had a new battery in the car that day. Great service and great prices. Will be back again.
