This rating is based on customer reviews, inventory size, pricing, and service quality
Mc Cullough Auto Parts in Evansville, IN trends positive overall: 88/100. Reviewers praise reasonable pricing, clear communication, and friendly, professional staff; several say repairs were done right the first time with good after-service. A notable outlier reports a 6‑week wait, immediate post-repair failures, and a dirty interior, raising concerns about consistency. Themes: great value and customer service, mixed repair durability, variable turnaround. Little info on inventory variety, yard organization, or ease of finding parts.
What clients say about Mc Cullough Auto Parts in Evansville (IN)
They had my vehicle for 6 weeks. Spent several thousand dollars. One of the things they fixed failed within 5 minutes of leaving. The other major repair they did, the parking brake, broke two months after leaving. They also gave me my car back with the interior covered in greasy filth.
Was the least expensive place in town to do my water pump and close to home. They done a fantastic job, didn't change the price and kept me in the loop during the process. (Was a partial motor teardown, which is extreme for a part you have to normally replace ESPECIALLY when the design has flaws. Thanks designers!) But they dealt with the fix, parts and the after service was great. Best part, I knew when I got in my car, it was fixed! No bandaid, no rigging it up. FIXED! I recommend their service highly!
1310 Stringtown Rd, Evansville, INCar repair and maintenance service
1617 Wedeking Ave, Evansville, INAuto parts store
Website
