What clients say about Colgate Auto Care in Colgate (WI)
Went in expecting brakes and rotors on all four and was told the fronts still have life for a while in them. Appreciate the honesty of not trying to sell something I didn’t need today. Also had the rear differential oil replaced all in one day. I also appreciate the 10% discount for new customers. I will be back!
Jake was very easy to talk with about the service needed on my daughter’s first car, we had a muffler noise that suddenly happened, which to a teenage girl rolling in to school sounding like she’s driving a diesel engine is the end of the world. I spoke to Jake about trying to get her car in asap, which he did, and that we wanted to keep cost down as this was a budget car. Jake came up with a couple options, and he had her car in and out very quick, everything sounding so much better. I especially appreciated the communication and pricing was fair. I will be coming back. :)
I genuinely have so many thanks to give to Jake and his company! I was constantly on the phone with BMW and at their shop to try and resolve my missing Apple Carplay. They were NEVER able to fix it, and both lied and gave up on me multiple times.
Jake on the other hand, took painstaking time and energy into resolving my Carplay issues. He never abandoned this project, and he literally fixed a severe malfunction my car was having. He is an awesome guy, and an ever harder worker. I highly recommend this location.
I have been going to Jake for auto work ever since I purchased my first company truck.
Owning a contracting company makes for a very sporatic schedule.
Jake has always managed to get me in with shorter than preferred notice, his prices are very fair, and him and his team do very quality work!
I will be bringing all of my vehicles to Colgate Auto Care.
Jake, ya got a lifetime customer!
Bought 4 new tires from Colgate Auto Care. Very competitive price, great service by Jake and his crew. A pleasure to deal with and love the fresh look on the building!
Been putting off the "Service Tire Pressure Monitoring System" error message for too long. Called Jake and scheduled an appoinment for the next day. Less than an hour he and his crew had my vehicle set to go. Problem solved! Quick and freindly service, fair pricing, and nice waiting area too. Highly recommend.
Jake did an amazing job fixed a problem that nobody else was able to figure out he took his time did lots of research and was able to get our issue solved great communication and just an all-around super nice guy to deal with! I highly recommend Colgate auto care!!
Jake and his team did a great job on my BMW M4. I had him change out my extremely low profile summer tires for winter tires. This is definitely the hardest tire change to do, and his team did it flawlessly. After I inspected the wheels there was not a single scratch on any of the wheels. I will definitely be back in spring to have my summer tires put back on the car.
Had Tire mounting and balancing, was easy to schedule, accommodated my schedule, service was completed quickly and work was done well, Jake was very kind and friendly. Building is nice. Pricing was very fair. All around pleasant experience
I brought one of our cars to Colgate Auto Care for an oil change. I was able to get in same day and the service was done very efficiently. I was out of there fairly quickly for a very fair price , and everyone I encountered there was super kind and nice. I highly recommend them! We will definitely be repeat customers.
I’ve been working with Jake at a previous location for many many years so when I found out that he opened his own shop I was happy to support him.
Not only is the pricing reasonable, but the mechanics are very knowledgeable in what they do and care about your time, not only getting it done quickly but efficiently as well.
The inside is spacious and comfortable to wait during your service.
I highly recommend Colgate Auto Care for any of your vehicles maintenance and service needs.
Went in for simile emissions check. Fast service clean waiting area and prompt service.
Then he explains he can get it all done for me... yes there was fee... but got me registration and even applied sticker.
Just was impressed with the place and attitude
Took me a week to get an appointment. Was told it would be done on Monday. Was told if they couldn’t get it done, would Tuesday be ok. Said they would let me know either way. No courtesy call for an update. Sat with no car until Wednesday. Not very professional at all.
Jake to the rescue!! Somehow we experienced 2 flat tires at the same time. Took 1 tire to several locations and they said could not be fixed. Called Jake he said bring it in. Went right over to Jake and low and behold all fixed. Needless to say brought the second tire in and he fixed as well. He was prompt, courteous and fair priced. Highly recommend !!! Thank you
Jake found a leak in my tire that had been missed by the previous service technicians at my normal service center. He was able to patch it and extend the life of my tire. I truly appreciate his attention to detail and willingness to take a look at my car on such short notice.
Excellent service. The owner, Jake, is very nice and they fit me in quickly to fix my AC in this awful summer heat. HIGHLY recommend for anyone looking for an auto shop!
Top notch ownership and operation. Amidst their buildout and move into this building they never dropped the ball. Jake and his team will treat you fair.
Jake and his team provided efficient service at a fair price in a timely manner. I was able to schedule an appointment for my vehicles service on a day and time that worked best for me. Thanks Colgate Auto Care!
My husband and I both brought our vehicles to Colgate Auto Care for oil changes and received nothing but excellent service. The experience was professional, efficient, and reassuring—we felt our cars were in great hands. The waiting area was clean and comfortable, and the owner, Jacob, was kind, friendly, and took the time to clearly explain any issues he found. We will absolutely return for any future automotive needs and highly recommend Colgate Auto Care to others.
Great guys, pricing is pretty fair. They made is such an easy experience, and being my local neighborhood shop, I’ll definitely be back. Highly recommend.
Congratulations to Colgate auto care.
Jake has been servicing our cars for years. Trusting someone to service your cars is a big decision, I would highly recommend you
To Give Colgate auto care a try. They are honest and upfront with
Your auto service needs. Thanks again Jake for getting me back
On the road.. Dick 4/02/25
Mike and his team have done an incredible job trying everything under the sun to get my daughter's car ready for emissions testing - all while managing an extremely busy and thriving business. The car has not been at all cooperative but he and his team have done everything they can to NOT make me have to buy a new catalytic converter, a very expensive car part, including getting involved himself in helping with diagnosis and problem-solving. He goes above and beyond to be honest with his customers and keep costs down wherever he can while also providing good quality repairs. Not an easy balance but he did it well (including spending 45 min on a call with me explaining all the different things they've considered and the whys/why-nots). Thank you.
These guys are awesome! After an oil change gone horribly wrong (not performed by them) they were able to take a look at my car the same day and had a new radiator put in by the next. I would highly recommend them for any vehicle services. They were very knowledgeable, professional, and fast!
Great service, great people and honest mechanics. I frequently go there for all routine maintenance on two of my vehicles and when I have a concern. They are always willing to take a look and provide their honest opinions about the state of my vehicle. Very lucky to have a great shop so close to home.
Mitech Automotive is great!
Not only are prices very fair, they were very up front with me regarding the necessary repairs vs expense. Mike and Todd are so pleasant to talk to. They did NOT talk down to me - though they certainly were so far above me with their knowledge of my vehicle and it's problems. They put me at ease and I placed all my trust in them. They did not disappoint. Will only go to Mitech from this point on!
