Conoy Car Company in
Bainbridge (PA)

Had a great experience buying my car from you guys my kids and I are very happy thank you so much would 100%recommend to anyone. Absolutely love my Chrysler Pacific

We were searching for a car for our granddaughter and found the perfect Subaru for her at Conoy Car Company. Keith worked with us to make the transaction a wonderful experience for her and get her the car that she loves. Keith is the perfect example of what a car salesman should be...I highly recommend dealing at this business!

My boyfriend bought a truck with Keith and we had an amazing experience. Complete transparency on prices and what he was paying for. We will definitely be back!!

Great experience with conoy car company. Keith went out of his way to make sure our granddaughter got the car she wanted. So glad we found this place, we will be back.

We were in the market for a Jeep Wrangler, and Keith helped us find just that. He was great to work with. He wasn’t pushy, let us take it on an extended test drive, and gave us tips on what to check on from other jeeps we were looking at. The price was fair, and he was great to work with! We will be back again!

Keith was great to work with and we are very pleased with the services he provided. The car was exceptionally clean inside the engine bay, interior, and exterior. He was very transparent throughout the entire process and was quite organized. We were interested in the warrenty options and he was very detailed and patient walking me through the options. It was great that we could get the paperwork done onsite and the new license plate right away. Keith was friendly, not pushy, and honest. While I'm sure this car will last us a long time, we'll certainly be back and would recommend his business to others. Thanks Keith!

Great sales pitch. Awful ownership experience. In 2023, I purchased a 2014 Jeep Grand Cherokee from Conoy Car Company. At the time, the buying process was smooth and friendly, and I was led to believe I was purchasing a reliable vehicle backed by a warranty. That confidence lasted about six months. After that, the Jeep became a constant source of problems. One issue turned into another, and over time I was forced to put nearly $15,000 into repairs just to keep it on the road. I paid extra for an extended warranty at the time of sale, but despite repeated attempts, not a single repair was ever covered. Four different garages tried to submit claims and all were given excuses, delays, or outright denials. One garage that claimed it worked with the warranty wouldn’t even complete repairs on several occasions. When I contacted the dealership for help, I was told “I’ll call you later.” That call never came. Repeated attempts to follow up were ignored, and eventually I was blocked by the owner by phone and on social media, which says everything about how problems are handled once the sale is complete. Shortly after the Jeep, I purchased a second vehicle from this dealership that was supposed to be a dependable family vehicle. Despite being inspected just days before purchase, I immediately had to spend around $4,000 just to make it road-safe. This included dry-rotted tires, brakes and rotors worn down to the metal, oil that was completely black, and broken components. That so-called inspection was clearly meaningless. Both vehicles were properly maintained. I did not put excessive mileage on them, and I have documentation to prove it. The excuse of “lack of maintenance” simply does not apply here. The real issue was being sold vehicles with serious problems and a warranty that turned out to be worthless. To make matters worse, there was zero accountability. Instead of offering solutions, the owner chose to ignore, deflect, and eventually cut off communication entirely. At that point, complaints were escalated to the appropriate state authorities. Bottom line: The sales experience may feel friendly, but once you drive off the lot, you’re on your own. Between unreliable vehicles, a useless warranty, and an owner who refuses to take responsibility or communicate, this dealership is not one I would ever recommend. Response to Owner: Your response contains multiple inaccuracies. I did not put 50,000 miles on the vehicle—please explain where that number came from. I also have full maintenance records and receipts, though no one from your dealership ever asked for them. The vehicle was problematic from the start. In fact, one garage refused to continue working on it once they learned where it was purchased. Six warranty claims were submitted and all were denied. If the warranty you sold actually functioned as promised, many of these issues would have been resolved. You did offer a trade-in, but only after asking me to pay an additional $5,000–$8,000, which is not a solution. Brakes, rotors, and tires were replaced within a month due to a failed inspection—on a vehicle your garage had just inspected. I am not seeking anything from this review other than transparency for future customers. Blocking consumers when they ask for help, deflecting responsibility, and dismissing valid concerns is a pattern reflected in other reviews as well. I am allowed to share my truthful experience. If constructive criticism feels like a personal attack, that speaks for itself. The post was rewritten due to only allowing so many characters on a review and since you contacted google to have the original review removed in the first place. No neglect just truth.

It was a pleasure buying a vehicle from Keith at Conoy Car Company. He was very personable and straight forward and made me feel very comfortable about buying a vehicle there. I feel he went the extra mile to make everything fall into place and answer any questions thoroughly. I will definitely be recommending him to friends and family. Thanks Keith!

It was a pleasure working with Keith. He is sure to explain everything to you so you know exactly what you’re signing. He is honest and we highly recommend.

We had a great experience with Keith at Conoy Car Company. Keith is both the owner and the person you work with, which made the process feel very personal and straightforward. He even came in on a Sunday so we could look over a car for our son, which we truly appreciated. He was very informative, answered all of our questions honestly, and helped make what could have been a stressful situation much easier. We never felt pressured at any point. I would absolutely recommend buying from Keith and Conoy Car Company.

We purchased a vehicle through this company on August 1. My daughter had really wanted a VW Beetle for her first vehicle, and since she had been working so hard, my husband and I told her that we would assist her in purchasing her first car for when she received her license. She searched for quite a while to find the perfect working Beetle with reasonable mileage. We went to the car company, and had a fairly smooth transition of purchasing the vehicle. Everything started off fairly well when the vehicle was in our possession. Unfortunately, that ended fairly quickly. The car had let my daughter and I sit when running an errand. We assumed that it was the battery, as the battery in the vehicle was older, so we changed the battery upon recommendation of our garage and the owner of the car company. Shortly after the battery died, both of the headlights died. It wasn’t just a bulb issue, when my daughter would drive over a bump, the lights would either come on or go off. So one night while we were driving, we were left with no lights and had to pull over on the side of the road. When we took the car to the garage for both the battery issue, we asked them to take a look at the lights as well. When the garage looked at the lights, they found that the headlights and the wiring had been glued into place as the lights were broken and it was “quick fix”. When I reached out to the owner of the car company, and explained the issues that we were having, I explained that these were issues that the garage felt should have been seen by the garage who inspected the vehicle prior to it being sold. When I reached back out to this car company, the owner explained to me that he didn’t feel that that was an item that would’ve been addressed and he wasn’t sure what was happening with the running of the vehicle or the lights. When I discussed the situation with him and what the garage said, he agreed to pay $500 of the lighting issue and issue with the battery connection issue. Needless to say, we are now into November and the car is still in the garage being fixed. The garage at this point feels that we were sold a bad car, and even though I have reached out to the owner multiple times for a resolution to the situation, we have gotten nowhere. Upon looking at other negative reviews, I see that there have been other similar issues like this. The Owner of the shop has now told me that we’ve had the car for several months and unfortunately, he thinks this is normal wear and tear. him that out of the few months that we’ve had the vehicle she’s driven it less than a month. Not even. So these issues were part of the vehicle upon purchase. When I asked the owner of the company about trading for another vehicle on his lot that was running to resolve the issue, he stated he would have to appraise the vehicle as is since it was not running. I’m just totally taken back by the responses, and the lack of accountability. I should have told my daughter we were going to search for another vehicle when we were sitting in his establishment and a female came in that worked for him and stated they were having an issue with the garage. They take their cars to prior to sale. This is quite a lesson learned for both myself and my child.

I had the amazing pleasure to do business with Keith— the whole process was nothing but over the top. Upon arrival he laid out carfax reports, reports of work he had personally done on the vehicle, and popped the hood to show me inside also. After the registration process you get a copy of everything, itemized bill, and title. He answered all of my questions with knowledge and ease and made me feel like I was apart of his family. I was officially switching residency from MD to PA and he helped me all the way and even with some turbulence between getting my new PA license and getting the car finalized. Keith was exceptional with his customer service also. He has free waters, coffee, candy, inside restroom and a gleaming smile. He gave my mother personal transportation money to get her from MD to PA, extended to lend a car if my car needed to be in the shop for any reason, and made it known he care deeply for both his customers and his cars. I had a question a few hours into driving my CRV and let him know and he called me within 5 minutes. If you are searching for a car and are apprehensive about if you’re getting a good deal and a good car, come here. He is 100% transparent about all details and if you’re not happy, he’s not happy. He WILL go the extra mile for you, so wherever you are, take that extra few miles to come see him! 💓

Keith, the owner, stopped on a Sunday when he happened to drive by and saw us looking at jeeps on his lot. He answered all of our questions and even allowed us to take the jeep we were looking at, for a test drive, even though he wasn’t even open for business! He gave me all weather car mats, free of charge, along with other extras that he didn’t have to give. He is a very honest person and a GREAT person to do business with. I highly recommend him if you’re in the market for a vehicle!

Keith is incredible! He’s so transparent with everything from start to finish. He gave us a great price and was a pleasure to deal with! Very personable and all around great experience! If you’re in the market for a new used car go see him !

If you’re looking for a hassle free, transparent, honest car buying experience, you need to stop in and talk with Keith. He is amazing at building rapport and wanting to do everything he can to make you happy and find you exactly what you’re looking for. He goes above and beyond to exceed expectations. We are extremely happy, that we purchased two vehicles from him in one week. Definitely going to him for any future car buying needs. Can’t say enough great things about our experience. Thank you, Keith. We love our jeeps.

I will be buying all my future vehicles through Keith. He is honest, trustworthy, and transparent. He doesn't pressure you in any way. In fact, he is very respectful and will listen to what kind of car you want and stick to your budget. He's great at communicating throughout the process and was so organized and efficient. I felt right at home talking with him. He's super friendly, very kind, and genuinely cares about people. I honestly felt like I knew him my whole life. He made the car-buying process so simple and so easy. Highly recommend!

Today 6/24/25,I purchased a 2014 Ford Edge Limited from Keith Morris at Conoy Car Company. He was very knowledgeable and helpful with going over all the details for the application. I am so happy that I had the opportunity to deal with Keith. I would recommend him very highly.

Keith was fantastic to work with! He was very thorough in explaining the details of the car and the paperwork involved. He took the time to walk us through the vehicle’s features and made sure we were completely satisfied. He even added a special touch by presenting the car with a big red bow! Keith was also willing to work with us on pricing, making the entire experience smooth and enjoyable. We will definitely be returning as repeat customers!

Excellent dealership! We told Keith our vehicle requirements and what we prefer. He gave us many options and different ideas to think about while trying to get to know us. After two weeks he found us what we were looking for and gave us a great deal on the car. Working with Keith was easy and pleasant. He made the purchasing process painless and fun. Great communication and he even setup a free Sirius Radio trial in our car. I wish I could give ten stars! We'll be back when it's time to buy another vehicle.

Definitely recommend anyone looking for a vehicle to come to Keith. My husband and I ended up in a bind when we couldn't afford to fix my car to pass inspection. We went to Keith and he talked us through everything we needed and found a vehicle in our price range on short notice. Keith is super helpful, to the point and, transparent about everything. He's friendly and doesn't pressure or hassle to buy any one specific car. Definitely recommending him to everyone i know to buy a car from him and will definitely go to him again.

Amazing dealership. We needed something affordable but dependable for our 16 year old daughter, so we contacted Keith. He was completely open about everything and answered all of our questions on each of the vehicles we looked at. He gives you the carfax report and also gives a 90 day warranty on all of his vehicles. We ended up getting her an amazing Honda CR-V, in incredible condition at a great price. Our daughter is absolutely thrilled. Keith has a lot of experience and is entirely trustworthy. I highly recommend Conoy Car Company. It feels good knowing she is in a dependable vehicle! Thank you Keith! 😃

Great car company to come check out!!! It's kinda out of the way in Bainbridge, but the savings are worth the trip!! Keith was able to work with my low credit and get me approved!!

Keith made the process of finding my husband a truck simple, transparent and super quick. Keith was very forthcoming and honest from start to finish. At no point did we feel pressured or unsure. I would recommend Conoy Car Company 10 times over! The fact that we could support a local business made this amazing process all the better. Thank you Keith!

This is a very small owner / operator business with GREAT honesty and total transparency. Considered our emotional attachment to our old beloved trade in and gave us the best deal on it. Walked us through the best financing options and sold us an outstanding SUV in wonderful condition at a great price. We're very happy after doing business here!! Thank you!!

Keith was incredible to deal with. I found the truck advertised on facebook marketplace and reached out with some questions to which he was super responsive. We ended up making a trade, my 2018 Tacoma for his INCREDIBLE condition 2010 Ford F150. I got a fair price for the Tacoma and his price for the Ford was more than fair. He handled everything quickly, professionally, and didn't nickel and dime me at all. Actually, he even paid for my second set of keys to be made AND offered to reimburse me for the first oil change! A really great, honest, car salesman, and how often can you say that?! I'm obsessed with the new truck, and look forward to working with Keith again in the future!

Got a nice car at a good price. Looked like every car on the lot was is in great shape. Keith was very detailed with the vehicle records and showed a willingness to work with my budget. I just wish it was groceries so I could come back every week. Oh well. See you in a few years. UPDATE: After 16 months and +15k miles she still runs great and I've had only had minor issues and maintenance.

Keith was honest and fantastic to deal with. I was looking specifically for a Ford Expedition. Since I had a bit of a longer drive to get to this location, I called to confirm that the vehicle was still there and available. Keith took the time to go over the Inspection report and Carfax with me over the phone before I even arrived. When I arrived, there was no pressure to buy, and the vehicle was exactly as he had described it. I would definitely buy from Conoy Car Company again. Thanks Keith!