Maine Street Auto in
Cumberland Center (ME)

Customer service goes above and beyond at Maine Street Auto. Matt and Kylie are local business owners who truly care about their community — trustworthy, honest, and just downright good people. They take real pride in their work, and it shows. Whether it’s car repairs or buying a reliable vehicle, this is the ONLY place I’ll go. Support local, and go where you’re treated like family

Matt and his team are the absolute best. If you need auto repair, tune ups, oil changes, have questions or concerns, or are in the market for a used car, Main Street Auto is who you can trust. And…in today’s world where customer service is mostly nonexistent, Matt goes above and beyond. 10 stars on all! The Town of Cumberland is so lucky to have you here.

Amazing customer service and very kind people! I would absolutely recommend them to anyone looking to buy a car in the area. I had no prior experience here, but stopped in to see one of the cars, and the people and atmosphere blew me away. No pressure and very honest too for the whole process. I ended up buying a 2015 Subaru Forester. Matt was excellent to work with!

Matt and Kylie recently helped my mother to get a new car purchased from their business. Kylie listened to hear her needs and Matt made the buying process incredibly easy. It’s very clear they love to help people through the process, love the work they do and most importantly love each other. I would and have recommended them to anyone and everyone I come across. We will definitely come here for our next purchase and hope to work with them for years to come. Truly wonderful honest people.

I didn’t know Matt prior to inquiring about one of the trucks he had listed for sale, but from our first interaction, he was responsive, professional, and easy to work with. When I met him in person to look at the truck and take a test drive, he was knowledgeable, transparent, and personable. The vehicle was exactly as described—clean, well-maintained, and priced fairly. What stood out most was how comfortable and pressure-free the entire experience was. It’s clear that Matt values honesty and integrity in how he does business, and that made the buying process feel straightforward and trustworthy from start to finish. I’ll absolutely recommend Maine Street Auto—and especially Matt Almy—to anyone looking for a quality used vehicle. It was refreshing to work directly with the owner, someone who clearly cares about his customers and the reputation of his business. I’m grateful to have found a reliable, locally owned family dealership, and I’ll definitely be returning in the future. Thanks again, Matt!

When my vehicle got a flat tire and I discovered there were no roadside assistance companies available in the area, I decided to call Main Street Auto on a whim to see if they offered the service. Although it’s not something they typically provide, the owner didn’t hesitate to jump in and help. His response was immediate, kind, and above all, genuine. My husband has always spoken highly of Main Street Auto, and after this experience, I can confidently say we’re both loyal customers for life. It’s rare to find a business that cares this much. Cumberland is lucky to have them.

I cannot believe that it’s possible to have a such a pleasant experience purchasing a vehicle. We saw all the good reviews but were in disbelief until we experienced it for ourselves. We’ve been to several other car dealers and have walked away because the sales people treat you like you’re stupid and try to pull their tricks and scam you every way they can. Matt at Maine Street Auto does not operate his business this way! He and his team exuded integrity. He treated us like friends in a genuine way, not because he wanted to make a sale. He prices his vehicles right and we are happy with the quality. Notably, this process took half the time as it would at any other dealer (including a trade in). Was a pleasure to do business with you Matt, thank you! Also - I was never asked leave a review, and I rarely leave reviews but this business deserves to be spoken highly of.

Needed reliable used car for tall, semi-broke college student. Matt was great. Had a SUV that was clean, not horribly old, with less than 100k miles. Provided not only car fax, but all maintenance records. Told us, if we had any problems, to come back to him and he would take of it. Car is perfect so far. No problems at all. Would highly recommend Matt and Maine Street Auto.

We weren’t in a hurry to buy a car, so after considerable research, we came across Matt’s dealership. I was surprised to see a 5-star rating, especially for a car dealership. After some digging, I decided to pack up the family and head down to test drive a Toyota Corolla. From the start, I was impressed with Matt. He was incredibly kind and personable. His dealership was clean. He texted with me throughout the process. During the test drive, we noticed a noise, which Matt also picked up on. He offered to inspect the car himself, which eventually led to a $5,000 transmission replacement—fully covered by him. Remarkably, he sold us the car at the original listed price. No doubt he lost money in the transaction, but he was committed to a "good sale." A few weeks later, after we brought the car home, another small issue surfaced. Matt promptly took care of that repair as well. Matt is deeply committed to selling cars in good working condition. His prices are fair, and the customer service is exceptional. I’d highly recommend his dealership. My next car will be from Matt as well.

I first met Matt when I took my friend to Maine Street Auto to look at cars to replace hers, which had been totaled in an accident. She was so nervous about finding a vehicle that she liked, that would feel safe to her, and that would work with her budget. Matt treated my 78 year old friend with such kindness, respect, and patience, and fully supported her during her car-buying experience. She told me that she felt that Matt was a very kind and trustworthy individual and that she loved her car. Her son was very impressed with the extended warranty and the very comprehensive and detailed paperwork that she received for her car. It was obvious to me that Matt, his wife, and his team fully understand and consistently demonstrate what exceptional customer service should look like. Just last week, I made my way to Maine Street Auto for repair on my own car, and it will definitely be my go-to place in the future. Much appreciation to the Maine Street Auto team!!

This is the best car buying experience I've ever had. My husband and I felt completely confident buying from Matt because he operates his dealership like nobody else we've met. Now I'm sending our daughter to Maine Street Auto because we trust him. Highly recommend!

It was the easiest, most hassle free car buying experience I've ever had. Matt was so nice, and he will stand behind anything he sells. I definitely will be doing business with him again when my daughter is looking for a car. Thank you for following up with me after the purchase!!

Start to finished the BEST buying experience I have ever had! Working with Matt was like being advised by a trusted friend. Do enter this experience with the term 'used car' in mind. Matt knows cars and only procures reliable vehicles that will fit his customer's needs. I will be a repeat customer!

Such a great experience buying from Matt at Maine st auto! He was honest and easy to work with. I brought the car to a mechanic before buying and the one part that had a problem Matt said would fix for free. I’m so happy with my vehicle, not to mention was at an amazing price! Beyond happy.

The service cannot be beat! My 87 year old mom got a flat tire when she was visiting from out of town, and pulled in for help. The mechanic put the spare on the car for her so she could get back to my house, (at no charge to just help her out), ordered a new tire, and the next day put it on for us. They could not have been nicer or more helpful! Every time I have taken the car to them, it is reasonably priced for the service, and completely reliable. I also bought a used car from them in May 2023, and have had no issues with it at all - loved the price I paid and love the car!

Matt was very friendly, helpful and supportive throughout the purchase process - going above and beyond our expectations. We will be comfortable recommending Matt and Maine Street Auto. The only sad note is that we really enjoyed getting to know Matt and now that our purchase is complete we won’t have regular interactions!

You won't find a better experience! I was looking for a good, reliable first used car for my youngest son at a good price point. Matt listened carefully to what I and my son wanted and was able to quickly meet our need. He found the perfect car for my son within my budget. Listening to Matt, I also know he stands behind the cars he sells, leaving me with even more confidence. My son loved his new car. Thanks Matt!

I couldn't be happier with my purchase and experience at Maine Street Auto! The process was very smooth and I felt comfortable at every interaction. What I loved most was the casual, yet professional atmosphere. It was a real family affair - working with Matt was great and I really enjoyed meeting other members of the family. Never before has buying a car been so easy, stress free, and dare I say... Fun! I highly recommend!

I strongly recommend working with Maine Street Auto if you're looking to buy a used car. My partner and I bought a car from Matt in February after finding the listing online. He was super transparent throughout the entire experience: he honestly described the condition of the vehicle during our first phone call, he was happy to jack up the vehicle for us to inspect the frame, drivetrain, and running gear and also let us check the engine fluids and transmission during the test drive. I found that he priced our vehicle very fairly based on its (honestly pretty good) condition and the market and he was very upfront about his buying process. The warranty included with the vehicle purchase was generous and comprehensive, and Matt was extremely flexible with us when it came to needing some minor work on the car (I want to note that this work was not overlooked by Matt's shop--this was an issue that could not be addressed preventatively and was not essential to the operation of the vehicle). Overall, Matt at Maine Street Auto was extremely pleasant to work with and he sold us a quality vehicle. If had to buy another used. car in New England (I sure hope I don't ;)) Maine Street Auto would be my first stop.

I have nothing but great things to say about Maine Street Auto. After unfortunately totaling my vehicle, I was left with a limited time frame to find a new car. After seeing a car at Maine Street Auto that I was interested in, my father and I went to check it out. From the second we arrived, Matt was present, but not pressuring. After checking out the vehicle and test driving it, we were almost positive it was the perfect car for me. However, we needed a little more time to get everything sorted out. Matt had no hesitations of taking the vehicle off the market (without a deposit) under good faith we would be back. He and the company 100% represent the small Maine community feeling of taking care of each other. I had one issue with my trunk getting slightly jammed at times and within two minutes of calling, he had a part ordered and was ready to fix it. This car has been exactly what I wanted and more, and I know I can always trust Matt and his company to assist me if anything does go awry.

We made the drive all the way from Worcester today, and it was so worth it! We had a great experience buying a used car here. There was absolutely no pressure, and Mark was so accommodating. We were even able to bring our dog inside to help us with the shopping process! I would absolutely shop here again; I also appreciated the warranty they offered, as it helped me buy with more confidence.

Matt & Mark conduct Maine Street Auto the "way car buying is supposed to be"! You could never ask for a better car dealership to buy cars from due to their utmost integrity, honesty and making car buying fun once again! I bought 3 cars from them and would never go anywhere else -- period. Thank you. Keep up the fantastic work! Mark Rabinowitz, Portland

Fantastic job with detailing our vehicle. This is our family suv and with the two kids and dog, it takes a beating. Got it back looking brand new. Great communication and service. Would recommend to anyone.

My partner and I had the best experience buying a car from Matt and his wife. Super genuine, extremely transparent, he gave us so much information and made the process of buying a car fun if you can imagine! It feels great to have the warranty and to be buying a vehicle from a local family that you can 100% trust! We will only be coming here for our future auto needs!!:) A huge thank you to Matt and his wife for being awesome!

Maine Street Auto will absolutely take good care of you! Mark made it a very pleasant car buying experience. Ran into some unpredictable issues with the car after the purchase and they did not hesitate to get it fixed and make things right. They certainly value their customers and will go out of their way to make sure you are 100% satisfied with your purchase. Thanks!

The most positive car buying experience I’ve had! Mark and Matt are friendly, reliable and went above and beyond to help. Living in Portland, it’s not always easy to commute in the middle of a work day. Mark was able to complete 95% of the process over phone/text and I spent a total of 10 minutes in the dealership signing paperwork. He even stayed late waiting for me! I highly recommend buying a vehicle here - not to mention their Service Center has saved me multiple times with my previous car. I’ll definitely be back!

Our experience buying from Maine Street Auto was exceptional. Mark and Matt go above and beyond to make the process easy, transparent, and (dare I say) enjoyable! Unlike many corporate dealerships, Mark and Matt take the time to make personal connections - you can tell that they truly care about the customer on a personal level. We were pleasantly surprised that they offer a long term powertrain warranty - for free! We have nothing but great things to say about Maine Street Auto. Highly, highly recommend!