Every time I call or go in there I'm always met with a smile or pleasant greeting. They have always worked with me to try and get me what I need, whether selling or buying. They have the best prices for silver right now too, I called 9 other places. Thanks guys, you always do a great job!!!
Found this coin shop via a recommendation from a friend. The recommendation was a good one. They did not disappoint. We took them a very eclectic large collection from a relative's estate. The Gold and Coin of Fishers staff were knowledgeable, prices offered were fair, and customer service oriented. I would definitely return to this business.
I went to sell some bullion and the staff were very friendly and fair. They helped me test my bullion to confirm its authenticity and then offered a fair market price. The whole deal was done in under 5 minutes. I occasionally purchase and sell bullion and I will return here in the future.
Great shop to buy silver or sell. I’m new to buying silver and the owner was friendly and helpful even thought they were busy. Will be back for more silver soon. Awesome shop!!!
I’ve been into Gold and Coin of Fishers a few different times and always been treated like an old friend or family member. I went to several other closer by shops but none gave me the same deals when I was buying OR selling! I drive across town for these guys.
I discovered Gold and Coin of Fishers via a recommendation from a customer early this year. Over the past few months, the owner and I have become good friends due to his genuine honesty and the way he treats his customers. If you know me, you know that I value honest businesses and Gold and Coin is one of the best! The selection is excellent and changes almost daily. They check everything that comes through the door with a Sigma to make sure it is not counterfeit. They have some of the most unique products that they created for numismatist like the Christmas advent calendar and really cool mystery box that is a ton of fun. Both products are a great value and are often worth WAY MORE than the cost! They also have a kids club to help the young ones learn about the hobby and get some pretty cool stuff along the way! You can't go wrong either buying or selling to Gold and Coin of Fishers. Stop in and tell them I sent you!
A+++ Scott and his team are amazing at what they do. Buying or selling they always take care of you with great prices. Their inventory seems to change each day so it's always great going back over & over to see what is new. Highly recommend
Huge shout out to Gold and Coin of Fishers. They came recommended to me on Facebook when I was looking to sell a gold necklace and pendant I had been holding on to. When I arrived they were friendly, helpful and knowledgeable. They quoted me for the pieces, and I advised I was going to get two other quotes before making a decision. They encouraged me to do so, but also said they would see me again soon. Well, not only did they give me the best offer out of 3 local businesses, but they honored their offer the next business day even though the rates had gone down. It’s clear why they have been in business so long, and I would highly recommend them to anyone looking to sell gold. Don’t waste your time with other buyers, they will offer you top dollar and provide you with excellent customer service!
Excellent customer service. They help new precious metal collectors understand the industry. Very fair buying offers. Worth the 40 minute drive for me everytime.
Satisfied Customer. I have been going to this business for over five years and if you are in the Indianapolis area stop by and take a look around and ask some questions I don't think you will be disappointed. It is the best coin shop in central Indiana that provides prompt, accurate service at a fair price with a nice inventory. I wasn't expecting to get paid about 95% of Bid or Spot price for my silver bullion coins, but they don't hesitate to pay you top dollar and have an accurate calibrated scale that is certified by the state and a cool neodymium slide and years of expertise. Enjoy!
We visited on 9/18 and 9/20/25. Both times we were greeted as soon as we walked in the door. Logan was honest and knowledgeable. He purchased all of our valuable currency and coin for a fair price. Highly recommend!
No games. No mess. These guys get straight down to business. At the same time Scott & Logan are friendly, and have a good eye in spotting fake precious metals. I’m new to Indianapolis and this is my first shop I’ve tried out, and it might be a little cliche, but I struck gold!
Our estate planning attorney recommended Gold and Coin so I took some loose coins in as a trial run...Logan passed the test with patience, expertise, and a nice check. We will definitely be back.
The passing of a loved one is always a tough time. It took a few months for me to bring in her jewelry and coins. They were compassionate, knowledgeable and kind. Highly recommend them!
We have been coming here for years to get fair prices on our silver and gold items. I’ve even told an out of town family member to come here when her local jeweler only offered her 50% of the days price on sterling silver. The team here is always friendly, kind and knowledgeable. A+++
Gold and Coin of Fishers is the best place to buy and sell coins. I've been there several times and never disappointed. Logan is very knowledgeable on the coins, and ALL prices are fair. Everyone is very nice and welcoming. If you are ever unsure where to go, I would definitely go here.
I have never been to a store like this and was hesitant to go in. The staff were friendly and quick to offer assistance. I had a lot of coins (and some bills) that I needed to have evaluated as part of my parent’s estate. Logan was extremely helpful and knowledgeable, and explained everything to me in great detail. He spent a lot of time going over everything and never tried to rush me through the process. He wrote down all the prices/offers and made sure I had all of my questions answered before leaving. I highly recommend this store to anyone interested in selling or buying coins, bills, gold/silver, or anything else!
Good Honest buyer and seller of precious metals. Found these guys through google. I will gladly drive 2 hours to do business with them from now on.. would highly recommend.
Very honest and extremely helpful. Visited for an estimate and review of several books of coins. Was educated about what I had while they reviewed the coins. I follow on tik/tok and what not and they are my preferred coin store to buy from, even though they are three hours from home. Thanks Scott!!!
Brought some old coins in on a whim just to see if they were worth anything. Turns out they were! Professional staff and gave a good amount of $$. Definitely recommend this shop.
Hot day. Estate coins to part with. No sweat transaction with the wonderful people here. Logan is awesome! Fair, probably the best percentage back in the city on old coins. Thanks again to the team at Gold and Coin!
I was anxious about letting go of my late mother’s small box of old coins and paper money. Some of the “treasures” were from foreign countries. Some was military script. Logan sorted, evaluated and explained everything right in front of me. I ended up feeling relaxed, happy and confident that I chose the right shop to do business with. They took everything I had for what I felt was a good price. Mom would have been pleased. Thank you, Logan!
Paid a visit here to sell some old jewelry, coins and currency I have collected over the years. Process was informative, very quick and highly satisfactory. Logan was very knowledgeable and friendly, answered my questions and I was paid on the spot. Definitely recommend this business for anyone looking to buy or sell. Friendly people.
Great place to buy and sell gold and silver coins and bullion. Metals can come and go really quick, and the store doesn't have long hours. It is one of few stores around that buys and sells the way you would imagine, so it's a gem. Platinum comes in on occasion as well. Nice folks with helpful attitudes.
This might be one of my favorite coin shops. Great selection and fair pricing. As a guy who visits coin shops throughout the US when I travel for work, I have come to appreciate the ‘teacher’ coin dealer. This is the dealer that realizes that the future of the hobby requires education and creating a positive, patient environment for customers…especially for young collectors. This shop has a Kids Club with hundreds of children, and provides complimentary periodically over the course of the year. Nice!
Website
